Legislation that would establish a virtual one-stop shop for health insurance options statewide has received at least some bipartisan support in Louisiana so far, despite staunch opposition and what one policy group calls “misinformation” from the idea’s biggest critics — Gov. Bobby Jindal and state Health and Hospitals Secretary Bruce Greenstein.
The concept of health care exchanges, or an “Amazon.com” of all things health insurance as termed by Wall Street Journal economics editor David Wessell, is one of the few components of Obamacare that boasted bipartisan support for its ability to increase competition and open up the health insurance market. The issue also has created a chasm of sorts between Republican governors, some of whom favor it and others, like Jindal, who oppose the idea.
Still, Louisiana is one of only a few states in the country that has not agreed to establish its own health-insurance exchange, according to a report from The Advocate. And if the Legislature sides with the governor and balks at the bill (SB 744) to create Louisiana’s own exchange system, Louisiana will “be stuck with the [exchange] that’s designed by the federal government” if the federal law survives the scrutiny of the U.S. Supreme Court, Wessell tells NPR in a recent interview.
The state bill, proposed by state Sen. Karen Peterson, D-New Orleans, would create a 19-member board to set up the exchange and also develop a Small Employer Insurance Exchange for small business owners looking to offer health insurance to employees. It won 6-2 approval from the Senate Insurance Committee May 3 in what Greenstein labeled “a very risky move.” The Senate Finance Committee, which delayed taking up the bill during its Thursday meeting, will likely address Peterson's measure Monday.
Hours before the start of Thursday's Finance Committee meeting, the conservative Pelican Institute on Public Policy published its “Five Reasons Not to Create an Obamacare Exchange,” encouraging lawmakers to vote against Peterson’s legislation:
Louisiana taxpayers should not be forced to fund a state exchange. Louisiana could expect to pay approximately $40 million per year to run the exchange. This money would come from the pockets of Louisiana taxpayers. If legislators elect not to establish an exchange, the federal government can create one, but Louisianans would not be forced to pick up the tab. Legislators should not stick their constituents with a $40 million annual bill to help implement an unpopular federal law. If Washington insists on an exchange, let them pay for it.
State legislators should not create a new bureaucracy that will be controlled from Washington. The federal government already prevents states from establishing sensible health care policies. President Obama’s health care law continues this unfortunate trend. Establishing an exchange will do nothing to address this problem. If anything, it will serve as a fig leaf for the federal bureaucrats who dominate health care policy. Legislators should look for opportunities to expand state autonomy over health care policy rather than participating in another exercise in central planning.
A state exchange will make it easier for the Obama administration to enforce troubling aspects of the Affordable Care Act. For example, creating an exchange would make it easier for the Obama administration to collect taxes that fund efforts to force religious employers to provide coverage for services they find immoral. Legislators who oppose this attack on religious freedom should not facilitate it by creating an exchange.
Firing back not long after was the Louisiana Budget Project, a nonprofit policy research organization that’s been largely critical of Jindal’s privatization efforts, with its own "fact sheet" on health-insurance exchanges:
A Louisiana health insurance exchange would be locally designed and run and financially self-sufficient. It will help an estimated 350,000 Louisianans get affordable health insurance and federal premium tax credits beginning in 2014.
In reality, the federal government will cover the cost of setting up a health insurance exchange and pay for its first year of operation. After that, the exchange can sustain itself without any state general funds through strategies that all other states are considering—like a modest fee on the new insurance company revenue generated by the sale of plans in the exchange or selling advertising on the exchange website.
The Pelican Institute derived its flawed estimate from the budget of the Massachusetts Connector, an exchange-like entity set up in that state in 2006. But the Massachusetts model isn’t a valid comparison for Louisiana. First, Massachusetts didn’t get any of the help with set up and operating costs that Louisiana would receive from the federal government. Second, the Connector’s costs include tax subsidies to help people afford their health insurance premiums because Massachusetts paid those costs under its reform. But the federal government will pay the full cost of these subsidies for Louisiana residents.
Unfortunately, Louisiana has declined all federal financial support so far — that’s the real bad budget decision.
The Pelican Institute claims that creating a state-based health insurance exchange will increase federal control.
The opposite is true. The federal health care law allows each state to set up its own exchange. States have broad flexibility to design and run their exchanges as they see fit. In fact, the exchange concept was originally developed by conservative think tanks, and for years enjoyed bipartisan support precisely because it provides a state-based solution and uses the private market to address the problem of unaffordable health insurance.
The Lafayette superintendent insists the budget is illegal and vows to fight on.
"I am not a scientist," Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell has said numerous times, a response that other members of his party have parroted.
Republicans are running strong races against endangered Democratic incumbents in states such as North Carolina, Colorado, Arkansas, Louisiana and Alaska. Republicans are also looking to replace retiring Democrats in Iowa and West Virginia with a GOP lawmaker.
Republican congressman Vance McAllister is trying to make up to Louisiana voters for getting too close to a married former employee.
You may not like all of “it,” but U.S. Sen. Mary Landrieu, unlike many of her colleagues, isn't sitting around twiddling her thumbs in Congress.
Saints safety Kenny Vaccaro says he "can't wait" to play against Green Bay quarterback Aaron Rodgers.
The heat keeps rising for Iberia Parish Sheriff Louis Ackal as a new slate of corruption allegations surfaced this week.
If opposing defenses sell out to stop the Packers' passing game, they risk being gashed by powerful running back Eddie Lacy, a New Orleans-area native.
At the horn the officiating crew trotted to the tunnel and left security personnel to clean up after them.
Friday's Blogs from the Bog!
Sign "ninjas" cleaning up clutter; NYC doctor positive for Ebola; Ferguson grand jury decision nears; and more national and international news for Friday, October 24, 2014.
We can safely assume incumbent Chief K.P. Gibson isn’t too worried about this challenger.
Nationally, Republicans must gain six seats to win Senate control. The most competitive races, many in states where Obama lost in 2012, remain too close to call.
The Baton Rouge Republican has repeatedly battled a perception within his own party that he perhaps wasn't the best choice to carry the GOP banner.
Even if Jimmy Graham's production dips while the star tight end recovers from a shoulder injury, it looks like Drew Brees won't have much trouble finding other targets.
A former campaign manager for Senate candidate Rob Maness is striking at the Republican contender's tea party support, saying Maness only sought to appeal to conservative organizations because he needed money for his campaign.
Ninety-two percent of public school teachers were rated either effective or highly effective in a report the state issued marking the second year of a new statewide evaluation process.
School board members Mark Babineaux, Hunter Beasley and Tehmi Chassion can vote to fire Cooper — because we all know that’s exactly what they’ll do.
District 2 school board candidate Simon Mahan is hoping to unseat first-term incumbent and former Carencro Mayor Tommy Angelle in the Nov. 4 election.
District Attorney Mike Harson is showing his desperation by falsely attributing quotes to his opponent and blocking journalists from his social media.
The governor is traveling the country laying the groundwork for a possible 2016 presidential campaign, but his approval ratings at home hover well below 50 percent.
State District Judge Bob Downing extended the order and delayed a planned Wednesday hearing about a permanent injunction while negotiations continue between Attorney General Buddy Caldwell and the waste disposal site operator.
New Louisiana higher education commissioner Joseph Rallo will be paid more than his predecessor.
Elijah McGuire and Alonzo Harris each had four rushing touchdowns, and Louisiana-Lafayette rolled to 419 yards on the ground in a 55-40 victory over Arkansas State on Tuesday night.
Bill and Hillary Clinton are the validators-in-chief for Democrats struggling through a bleak campaign season in states where President Barack Obama is deeply unpopular.