Wednesday, December 1, 2010
When it comes to the state’s Medicaid case management program, four weeks — and a lot of noise — made all the difference. By Jeremy Alford
[Editor's Note: This story had been modified from its original version.]
The 14th of September was Bruce Greenstein’s second day on the job as Louisiana’s new secretary of health and hospitals. From the first part of the day to the last, he quickly transitioned from the trivial — a “new media” initiative involving Twitter, YouTube and the like that he promised would “transform the way” his department interacts with residents, despite this being a state where 57 percent of homes have no Internet access — to the political, inserting himself into a legal proceeding that allowed a Shreveport abortion clinic to continue operating.
While Greenstein said the new media initiative was a “directive” from Gov. Bobby Jindal, it’s also likely that his official statement on the 19th Judicial District ruling was in line with what the top brass wanted as well. Jindal, a Republican with unquestionable national ambitions, ushered in a law in June making it easier for the state to shut down abortion clinics — and the governor has been bragging about this legislative accomplishment at every conservative fundraiser between Los Angeles and New York recently.
But it wasn’t until Oct. 22 when Greenstein popped his political cherry. That’s when he was forced to announce a $50 million funding deficit in Medicaid that was caused by unfunded increases in utilization. As a way to partly address this shortfall, Greenstein said DHH would be shuttering the state’s Primary Care Case Management Program, known as CommunityCARE, which was originally created to provide a “medical home” for Medicaid recipients.
Greenstein made no bones about his distaste for the program. Looking back, one could even argue that Greenstein was hellbent on trashing it, hated it even. “This program has failed to show the results promised and is a perfect example of why this model of managed care in Medicaid doesn’t work,” Greenstein said. “For our $6 million per year investment in state general funds, CommunityCARE has done nothing to make people healthier. In fact, we’ve actually seen reductions in some key health measures under the program. We can’t continue to invest in programs that do not deliver value by improving the health of the people they serve.”
Four weeks later, however, Greenstein was singing a different tune. The same program that had “failed” and “done nothing” would be revamped, not scrapped, he announced. In fact, when Greenstein addressed the House Health and Welfare Committee late last month, he offered up an explanation of bureaucratic proportions. “We are no longer eliminating the program,” he said. “We are eliminating the program as we know it.”
So, what happened? In short, DHH’s stakeholders flipped out. Health care providers, in particular, banded together to form the Coalition to Protect Louisiana’s Healthcare, which counts as its members the State Medical Society, Louisiana Ambulance Alliance, Louisiana Hospital Association, MedicineLouisiana and the Metropolitan Hospital Council of New Orleans. Specifically, the coalition is urging lawmakers and the administration to investigate solutions that “may be politically inconvenient, but necessary to protect access to health care.”
Dr. Andy Blalock of Lafayette, vice president of the Louisiana State Medical Society, says he was ready to hoot and holler about DHH’s proposed elimination of the Medicaid program — and by no means was he alone. “We already have an access to care issue,” he says. “If these cuts go forward, it will only get worse.” Blalock adds that physicians are already running away from the Medicaid program, and any significant changes that pull money away from physicians would only serve as a stronger repellent.
Blalock’s sentiment was mirrored all over the state this fall and winter, and may have caused Jindal’s health leaders to fold like a cheap suit when it comes to the matter of shuttering CommunityCare.
Tyron Picard, executive vice president of Acadian Ambulance, argues the original plan to scrap CommunityCare as a means to developing a new coordinated care network, or CCN — a network that would be run by private insurance companies — was actually created by Greenstein’s predecessor, Alan Levine.
But since Greenstein was hired, Picard says, health care providers have been given more of a voice. “To his credit, Secretary Greenstein not only heard the provider concerns about the original version, but acted upon those concerns by starting a statewide dialogue on how to tweak the CCN model to alleviate the concerns providers had about the ambiguities in the original version,” Picard says. “My experience has been that he has been attentive to the concerns raised, engaged in learning as much as possible about those concerns aired, and willing to dialogue about possible solutions. I have found him accessible and responsive.”
Greenstein now wants the revamped CommunityCare program, which takes effect Jan. 1, to serve as a “bridge” to the proposed coordinated care network that would be run by insurance companies. In case you haven’t heard, the Jindal administration has also pushed the implementation date of the proposed CCN to late 2011, at which time the governor and lawmakers will be done with the approaching election cycle — a period that is traditionally bereft of political courage.
The Coalition to Protect Louisiana’s Healthcare, meanwhile, is working on its own CCN proposal that will likely place the state’s existing providers at the helm. Once it’s introduced into the mix, it’s highly likely that everything will change again. But that’ll be par for the course. It will also serve as yet another reminder of how difficult it is to make tough decisions in state government — and how easy it can be to change them.
Struggling to preserve their Senate majority, Democrats are attacking Republicans over Medicare and Social Security in Louisiana, spending cuts in Arkansas, off-shore jobs in New Hampshire and women's issues in Colorado.
Saints safety Kenny Vaccaro says he "can't wait" to play against Green Bay quarterback Aaron Rodgers.
The heat keeps rising for Iberia Parish Sheriff Louis Ackal as a new slate of corruption allegations surfaced this week.
If opposing defenses sell out to stop the Packers' passing game, they risk being gashed by powerful running back Eddie Lacy, a New Orleans-area native.
At the horn the officiating crew trotted to the tunnel and left security personnel to clean up after them.
Friday's Blogs from the Bog!
Sign "ninjas" cleaning up clutter; NYC doctor positive for Ebola; Ferguson grand jury decision nears; and more national and international news for Friday, October 24, 2014.
We can safely assume incumbent Chief K.P. Gibson isn’t too worried about this challenger.
Nationally, Republicans must gain six seats to win Senate control. The most competitive races, many in states where Obama lost in 2012, remain too close to call.
The Baton Rouge Republican has repeatedly battled a perception within his own party that he perhaps wasn't the best choice to carry the GOP banner.
Even if Jimmy Graham's production dips while the star tight end recovers from a shoulder injury, it looks like Drew Brees won't have much trouble finding other targets.
A former campaign manager for Senate candidate Rob Maness is striking at the Republican contender's tea party support, saying Maness only sought to appeal to conservative organizations because he needed money for his campaign.
Ninety-two percent of public school teachers were rated either effective or highly effective in a report the state issued marking the second year of a new statewide evaluation process.
School board members Mark Babineaux, Hunter Beasley and Tehmi Chassion can vote to fire Cooper — because we all know that’s exactly what they’ll do.
District 2 school board candidate Simon Mahan is hoping to unseat first-term incumbent and former Carencro Mayor Tommy Angelle in the Nov. 4 election.
District Attorney Mike Harson is showing his desperation by falsely attributing quotes to his opponent and blocking journalists from his social media.
The governor is traveling the country laying the groundwork for a possible 2016 presidential campaign, but his approval ratings at home hover well below 50 percent.
State District Judge Bob Downing extended the order and delayed a planned Wednesday hearing about a permanent injunction while negotiations continue between Attorney General Buddy Caldwell and the waste disposal site operator.
New Louisiana higher education commissioner Joseph Rallo will be paid more than his predecessor.
Elijah McGuire and Alonzo Harris each had four rushing touchdowns, and Louisiana-Lafayette rolled to 419 yards on the ground in a 55-40 victory over Arkansas State on Tuesday night.
Bill and Hillary Clinton are the validators-in-chief for Democrats struggling through a bleak campaign season in states where President Barack Obama is deeply unpopular.
President Barack Obama is turning to black radio listeners to plead for midterm votes, a targeted approach to drum up Democratic support at a time when many candidates don't want him around in person.
"I am extremely disheartened by the political machines that are attempting to hijack my efforts along with others that advocate for children."
Landrieu, who is fighting to keep her seat for a fourth term, said that Ebola is serious and precautions should be taken, but she accused Republicans of using the virus outbreak in West Africa to "create fear" here at home.
Law enforcement agencies are participating in a "Louisiana Heroin Summit," designed to address the recent rise in heroin use and drug-related deaths around the state.