Wednesday, December 1, 2010
When it comes to the state’s Medicaid case management program, four weeks — and a lot of noise — made all the difference. By Jeremy Alford
[Editor's Note: This story had been modified from its original version.]
The 14th of September was Bruce Greenstein’s second day on the job as Louisiana’s new secretary of health and hospitals. From the first part of the day to the last, he quickly transitioned from the trivial — a “new media” initiative involving Twitter, YouTube and the like that he promised would “transform the way” his department interacts with residents, despite this being a state where 57 percent of homes have no Internet access — to the political, inserting himself into a legal proceeding that allowed a Shreveport abortion clinic to continue operating.
While Greenstein said the new media initiative was a “directive” from Gov. Bobby Jindal, it’s also likely that his official statement on the 19th Judicial District ruling was in line with what the top brass wanted as well. Jindal, a Republican with unquestionable national ambitions, ushered in a law in June making it easier for the state to shut down abortion clinics — and the governor has been bragging about this legislative accomplishment at every conservative fundraiser between Los Angeles and New York recently.
But it wasn’t until Oct. 22 when Greenstein popped his political cherry. That’s when he was forced to announce a $50 million funding deficit in Medicaid that was caused by unfunded increases in utilization. As a way to partly address this shortfall, Greenstein said DHH would be shuttering the state’s Primary Care Case Management Program, known as CommunityCARE, which was originally created to provide a “medical home” for Medicaid recipients.
Greenstein made no bones about his distaste for the program. Looking back, one could even argue that Greenstein was hellbent on trashing it, hated it even. “This program has failed to show the results promised and is a perfect example of why this model of managed care in Medicaid doesn’t work,” Greenstein said. “For our $6 million per year investment in state general funds, CommunityCARE has done nothing to make people healthier. In fact, we’ve actually seen reductions in some key health measures under the program. We can’t continue to invest in programs that do not deliver value by improving the health of the people they serve.”
Four weeks later, however, Greenstein was singing a different tune. The same program that had “failed” and “done nothing” would be revamped, not scrapped, he announced. In fact, when Greenstein addressed the House Health and Welfare Committee late last month, he offered up an explanation of bureaucratic proportions. “We are no longer eliminating the program,” he said. “We are eliminating the program as we know it.”
So, what happened? In short, DHH’s stakeholders flipped out. Health care providers, in particular, banded together to form the Coalition to Protect Louisiana’s Healthcare, which counts as its members the State Medical Society, Louisiana Ambulance Alliance, Louisiana Hospital Association, MedicineLouisiana and the Metropolitan Hospital Council of New Orleans. Specifically, the coalition is urging lawmakers and the administration to investigate solutions that “may be politically inconvenient, but necessary to protect access to health care.”
Dr. Andy Blalock of Lafayette, vice president of the Louisiana State Medical Society, says he was ready to hoot and holler about DHH’s proposed elimination of the Medicaid program — and by no means was he alone. “We already have an access to care issue,” he says. “If these cuts go forward, it will only get worse.” Blalock adds that physicians are already running away from the Medicaid program, and any significant changes that pull money away from physicians would only serve as a stronger repellent.
Blalock’s sentiment was mirrored all over the state this fall and winter, and may have caused Jindal’s health leaders to fold like a cheap suit when it comes to the matter of shuttering CommunityCare.
Tyron Picard, executive vice president of Acadian Ambulance, argues the original plan to scrap CommunityCare as a means to developing a new coordinated care network, or CCN — a network that would be run by private insurance companies — was actually created by Greenstein’s predecessor, Alan Levine.
But since Greenstein was hired, Picard says, health care providers have been given more of a voice. “To his credit, Secretary Greenstein not only heard the provider concerns about the original version, but acted upon those concerns by starting a statewide dialogue on how to tweak the CCN model to alleviate the concerns providers had about the ambiguities in the original version,” Picard says. “My experience has been that he has been attentive to the concerns raised, engaged in learning as much as possible about those concerns aired, and willing to dialogue about possible solutions. I have found him accessible and responsive.”
Greenstein now wants the revamped CommunityCare program, which takes effect Jan. 1, to serve as a “bridge” to the proposed coordinated care network that would be run by insurance companies. In case you haven’t heard, the Jindal administration has also pushed the implementation date of the proposed CCN to late 2011, at which time the governor and lawmakers will be done with the approaching election cycle — a period that is traditionally bereft of political courage.
The Coalition to Protect Louisiana’s Healthcare, meanwhile, is working on its own CCN proposal that will likely place the state’s existing providers at the helm. Once it’s introduced into the mix, it’s highly likely that everything will change again. But that’ll be par for the course. It will also serve as yet another reminder of how difficult it is to make tough decisions in state government — and how easy it can be to change them.
Parents and teachers who support the Common Core education standards sued Gov. Bobby Jindal Tuesday over his actions against the multi-state standards, accusing him of illegally meddling in education policy.
An arrest was announced this morning in connection with last week’s bomb scare at UL Lafayette.
Attorneys, judges and others interviewed by LaPolitics expect 15 to 20 district judge races this year.
"I feel like I'm under siege," an attorney said recently over drinks at Galatoire's Bistro in Baton Rouge. "We all do. Every time I turn around somebody wants a check. District attorney races. The judges. They're killing us."
As a requirement for running for Congress in the 6th District, former Gov. Edwin Edwards has filed his financial disclosure statement with the U.S. House showing his income in 2013 totaling $242,787.
Unlike those swindled by Bernie Madoff, the victims of Texas businessman Robert Allen Stanford’s Ponzi scheme won’t be getting any relief from the Securities Investor Protection Corp.’s emergency fund after a recent appellate court ruling.
Tuesday's Blogs from the Bog!
Prince George turns 1 today; crash victims' bodies headed home; homeless attacked in New Mexico and more national and international news for Tuesday, July 22, 2014.
The legal challenge is part of a continuing struggle over Common Core, which has become controversial since the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education adopted the standards in 2010.
The lone Democrat to announce he's running for governor, state Rep. John Bel Edwards, criticized Republican Gov. Bobby Jindal's budgeting tactics as "running the state like a big Ponzi scheme."
State police have arrested a 42-year-old Kaplan man in the July 7 hit and run fatality crash that killed a bicyclist on Louisiana Highway 92 near Milton.
Republican U.S. Rep. Bill Cassidy has picked up support for his U.S. Senate campaign from a former GOP competitor.
Lisa Hargis Smith lived a mysterious life as seen with her death earlier this month and its impact on the community of those who knew her, whether as a star student in Lafayette High’s class of ‘69, or later as a woman struggling with homelessness and mental illness.
Attorney Valerie Gotch Garrett will announce on Tuesday that she plans to run for the Division E seat of the 15th Judicial District Court.
Back in 2012, three Baton Rouge attorneys came to the aid of several disgruntled police officers with a high-profile lawsuit against the Lafayette Police chief and a number of higher-ups in city-parish government, but in a federal courtroom Thursday, their claims of conspiracy coupled with a lack of evidence backfired and the case was dismissed.
Gov. Bobby Jindal's administration intends to rework how it pays the private managed care networks that provide health services to two-thirds of Louisiana's Medicaid patients.
Gov. Bobby Jindal's administration is raising health insurance rates and cutting benefits for state employees and retirees, to keep their insurance program solvent.
Local, state and federal law enforcement officials spent much of Thursday reviewing their reaction to this week’s bomb threat, which led to the closure and evacuation of UL Lafayette and Girard Park, and a massive search Wednesday for two alleged explosive devices.
"We're not in a better place from the policy perspective than we were two weeks ago," says Education Superintendent John White, commenting on Thursday's face-to-face meeting with Gov. Bobby Jindal to discuss their dispute over Common Core.
Gov. Bobby Jindal appears to remain unmoved by offers of a compromise on procuring testing materials tied to the Common Core based on a terse statement his office released following a meeting Thursday with Superintendent John White.
Wednesday's Senate vote on contraception legislation is the latest example of Democrats' win-by-losing strategy, which forces Republicans to vote on sensitive matters that might rile women this fall.
A benefit will be held tonight at Romacelli Bistro in Youngsville to raise money for the family of fallen cyclist Lon Lomas.
After weeks of public disagreement, Gov. Bobby Jindal and Education Superintendent John White are sitting down to talk about standardized testing for the upcoming school year.
Two members of the Lafayette Parish law enforcement community who also serve on the Lafayette Parish Communications District will not be allowed to apply for the paid position of director of the agency.
After determining that the two reported bomb-like devices at Girard Park and UL Lafayette this morning were non-explosive, authorities have lifted the barricades, and an investigation into who was responsible is now under way.