Girard Park residents cry foul over city’s decision to seek its own ‘relief’ in a conniving neighbor’s lawsuit.
By Leslie Turk
Girard Park residents cry foul over city’s decision to seek its own ‘relief’ in a conniving neighbor’s lawsuit. By Leslie Turk
Girard Park residents’ ongoing battle with an unneighborly neighbor, attorney Jimmy Davidson, took an unexpected turn on Jan. 24 when a state district court judge ruled that if Davidson is successful in court, Lafayette Consolidated Government would be entitled to the same relief for property it owns in the area. That “relief,” as our Feb. 1 cover “Don’t Back Down” analyzed, is Davidson’s lawsuit against his neighbors to nullify a 1940 covenant that restricts Girard Park Drive frontage to residential use.
But those residents are asking the judge to nullify his judgment or grant a new trial, saying defendants in the original action were never served with the city’s intervention before the decision was rendered by District Judge John Trahan, nor were they served or given any notice that a hearing on the motion for judgment had been scheduled. “The first they thing they knew was a judgment had been signed,” says attorney Gary McGoffin, who has been hired by a group of Girard Park homeowners to help fight Davidson. What’s more, the residents claim, no evidence of any agreement of the involved property owners to terminate the covenant was presented to the court, and they say there is no proof as to the actual ownership of the property by LCG.
“We simply took advantage of [Davidson’s] suit to give us more options on the planetarium site,” City-Parish President Joey Durel says of government’s decision to intervene in the controversial lawsuit involving the Girard Park neighborhood.
LCG maintains that two of its properties, the former planetarium site and Heymann Memorial Park, are both part of the covenant in question. In Davidson’s effort to void the covenant and sell his 4.1 acres at Girard Park and Hospital drives at their highest commercial value, he has been gathering support from affected residents since the mid-1990s and claims to now have releases from owners of 50 percent-plus of the total acreage encumbered by the covenant. It appears that there are roughly 50 acres affected.
Residents opposed to Davidson’s lawsuit — he named 19 of his neighbors as defendants — fear that voiding the covenant will lead to more commercial intrusion in their historic residential setting. McGoffin is confident his clients can win in court, noting in part that Davidson has yet to present a plat to account for all the property encumbered by the act. Because of that, it’s unclear whether Davidson has the support he needs.
In a separate legal filing fighting Davidson’s effort to void the covenant, a group of Girard Park residents is asking the court to force Davidson to prove how much acreage is affected and that he has the required support among those property owners.
A hearing on the neighborhood’s motions is set for March 5 at 10 a.m.
LCG’s attorney, however, believes Davidson has already proven his case and is adamant that LCG is not taking sides. Mike Hebert told The Independent that after reviewing the matter, he concluded that Davidson “appears to have obtained the consents of a necessary number of property owners to have the restriction lifted.” Hebert says it is in LCG’s best interest to seek the same relief, which is why he filed the Dec. 14 Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. “As a general proposition, it is in the best interest of every individual property owner to have the most unrestricted use of its property available,” he says. “This proposition is even implicitly recognized by the Louisiana Civil Code, which, in Article 778, provides in pertinent part that ‘Doubt as to the existence, validity, or extent of building restrictions is resolved in favor of the unrestricted use of the immovable.’”
If LCG does not participate in the lawsuit, Hebert notes, it is legally questionable whether rulings in the suit would bind LCG or apply to LCG’s property. “In an effort to remove any doubt on that matter, my opinion was that LCG should intervene in the suit,” he says.
Hebert believes the intervention is a way to avoid the expense of future legal proceedings to determine whether the restriction applies to LCG’s property and stresses that local government was not requested to sign a consent to release the restriction from its property, nor has it not done so on its own. But whether LCG’s property will be counted is a matter for the court to decide. In his suit against his neighbors, Davidson argues that the city’s property should either be excluded from the percentage calculation or included and considered released because of its non-conforming use.
Hebert was authorized to take action by City-Parish President Joey Durel and says council approval for the legal maneuver is not required. “We simply took advantage of [Davidson’s] suit to give us more options on the planetarium site,” Durel says. “This building, as I understand it, can be nothing but a museum, period. As it deteriorates, it becomes blight in that neighborhood. When I first got in office, there was a minor effort to turn it into an oil and gas museum, which would have been an acceptable use. That effort failed, and there has been no further discussion from anyone. So, when we saw that Davidson was trying to get some relief, we saw an opportunity to help give us some flexibility.”
But Girard Park residents who are battling Davidson — the current president of the Louisiana State Bar Association who once surreptitiously ran a plastics manufacturing business on his residentially zoned property — say because the city is seeking the same relief as Davidson its intervention serves to help his cause. They believe the city’s action was premature and that they were intentionally, and improperly, left out of the process.
“I have no idea what [Hebert] looked at. When I checked out the suit record, there was no evidence. I don’t know if they put any evidence in,” McGoffin says.
For their part, Davidson and LCG have teamed up to ask the judge to reconsider his ruling and are asking the court to rehear the case at the same time, in essence acknowledging that the defendants were not properly notified of LCG’s intervention.
OK, so they’re bentgrass, the type used on golf course greens. But grass is grass.
The Senate Finance Committee approved the bill Wednesday, despite opponents who argued it would shut down the storefront lenders.
A measure to allow the state to implement its own, less stringent plan for limiting carbon dioxide emissions unanimously passed the Senate.
FDA to regulate e-cigarettes, Jodie Foster gets married, Vermont to require labels on genetically-modified food, and more news for today, April 24, 2014.
Thursday's Blogs from the Bog!
A push to expand Louisiana's Medicaid program as allowed under the federal health care has been overwhelmingly rejected by the Senate health committee.
Louisiana welfare recipients would be prohibited in state law from spending the federal assistance at lingerie shops, tattoo parlors, nail salons and jewelry stores, under a bill that received the support Wednesday of a House committee.
Senators will consider whether to prohibit private businesses in Louisiana from paying unequal wages to employees of different genders for the same job.
Rep. Joel Robideaux has delayed bill hearings and said unless a compromise can be reached, he won't bring up the legislation this session.
Once again, Lafayette Parish School Board President Hunter Beasley is focused on an issue that has nothing to do with the educational well-being of our public school children.
After exhausting his appeals all the way to the state Supreme Court, the owner of the Tiger Truck Stop in Grosse Tete has no legal remedy left save one: do an end run around the high court via a bill that would grandfather his “right” to keep a 550-pound tiger enclosed in a pin at his roadside business.
Louisiana poet Darrell Bourque has won the 2014 Louisiana Writer Award, given annually to recognize outstanding contributions to Louisiana's literary and intellectual life.
Drivers would have to secure dogs riding in truck beds while on interstate highways, if the Senate agrees to a bill backed by the House.
An effort to prohibit employers from discriminating based on sexual orientation or gender identity was shelved Tuesday for the legislative session.
Louisiana won't lessen its penalties for marijuana possession, keeping laws on the books that allow people to be jailed up to 20 years for repeat offenses of having the drug in hand.
“This is one of the oldest divides that exists, and that divide is about the haves and the have-nots.”
It took a few weeks for the pitfalls to emerge in the governor’s $25 billion budget, but the time of judgment has finally arrived.
With pressure continuing to build for him to resign, Congressman Vance McAllister announced plans recently to remain secluded during the Easter break, but the Swartz Republican has said he’ll be back on the Hill casting votes and attending committee meetings when the congressional recess ends April 28.
A bid to limit the use of unmanned aircraft on private property in Louisiana stalled Monday in the Louisiana Senate.
A Shreveport lawmaker said Monday he's scrapping his proposal to name the Bible as Louisiana's official state book.
Attorney hopes fellow lawyers will join him in urging the D.A. to step aside and allow a competent, ethical challenger to take over the scandal-ridden office.
An official with the Louisiana Department of Education was arrested on a range of charges Friday after allegedly breaking into a home and brandishing a knife.
State Rep. Stuart Bishop says he’s concerned with the quality of Capitol Lake, but when it comes to Louisiana’s coastline, this Lafayette Republican doesn't seem to give a damn.
Democrats sweating this year's elections may be hoping that the Obama administration's latest delay to the proposed Keystone XL pipeline takes a politically fraught issue off the table for the midterms.
Louisiana lawmakers are entering the second half of their three-month regular legislative session, which must end by June 2. Where some of the major issues stand: