Doug Crawford was skeptical from the start when his company first decided to bid on a contract with Lafayette Consolidated Government to provide GPS monitoring for parish-owned vehicles. The request for proposals sent out by LCG contained several specifications that would directly favor a local company getting the contract, and the scuttlebutt was that Acadian Monitoring Services (a subsidiary of Acadian Ambulance) had assisted LCG with filling in the details of its RFP. In part because it has a local partner in Lafayette to help meet many of those demands, Crawford’s Trenton, Fla.-based FAS Systems decided to submit a proposal anyway.
It was one of 12 companies to answer the RFP. Only two of those, Acadian Monitoring and Consolidated Safety, are based in Lafayette.
A couple of weeks after the proposals were all received and accepted by LCG, Crawford got an e-mail: Lafayette Consolidated Government had decided to take a mulligan. All the bids received would be discarded and a new RFP, with new specifications, was being sent out. Crawford says he received no explanation for why this was happening. Upon hearing the news, his suspicions deepened, and he immediately picked up the phone and demanded that his company’s original proposal be sent back.
“It just reeks of some improprieties,” Crawford says. “We put in sealed bids which were opened then canceled, then re-bid. It makes me wonder who looked at my numbers. My question is, is someone [with a competitor] on the inside?”
Crawford has been with FAS for more than 15 years and bid dozens of contracts with local governments. “I’ve never had this happen before,” he says. At the very least, he claims the RFP process was mishandled and reflects poorly on Lafayette. “The level of professionalism? I’d have to put it really low, whether anybody looked at all the bids or not,” he says.
“It just stinks,” he continues. “I just can’t believe that you go out with an RFP on a project that size and then you screwed it up and have to re-bid it. I’m sorry, somebody looked at all those bids.”
LCG Chief Information Officer Keith Thibodeaux, who has been overseeing the GPS contract for LCG, insists the bid process has not been compromised, even though technically the proposals appear to have been subject to public record law for several days between the time they were accepted and the point LCG chose to cancel its initial RFP.
“They have not been distributed at all,” Thibodeaux says.
“I can assure you there is no fix,” he adds. “Now, do I blame the vendors for being upset about having to do work twice? No. Would they need to be upset that a competitor saw their bid? I wouldn’t blame them for being upset, but I can tell you that didn’t happen in here.”
Proposals for consideration on the contract, valued at $390,000, are now due by Jan. 12. Thibodeaux expects to have a contract signed by the end of February.
Thibodeaux says he wrote both RFPs that went out, basing them on a similar RFP from Cumberland County government in Tennessee. He did consult with Acadian Monitoring during the process, but says that he also discussed the RFP with reps from two other potential vendors, AT&T and Verizon. He also called officials at Stone Energy and Fenstermaker & Associates, two companies that contract out for GPS services.
City-Parish President Joey Durel has made equipping hundreds of LCG vehicles with GPS tracking devices a priority in his 2010 budget. Citing examples from other cities, Durel says that closely monitoring city-parish vehicles will result in big fuel and overtime savings. The issue briefly put the mayor at odds with the council during budget hearings. Councilman Jay Castille’s motion to strip the $395,000 set aside for the initiative won a majority vote from the council, only to be vetoed by Durel. (The council did not have a two-thirds majority to override Durel).
Thibodeaux says the council’s reluctance to fund the project prompted a decision to draft a new RFP, which he claims requires less of a commitment from LCG. “At that point,” Thibodeaux recalls, “we said, ‘you know what, I don’t know that we want to put ourselves in a position where we can’t easily get back out of this thing, because what if next year we don’t get the funding?’”
Thibodeaux says he discussed the issue with LCG Chief Administrative Officer Dee Stanley, and then authored the memo himself canceling the initial RFP.
“If you don’t know you’re going to have the money to continue it, then you don’t want to make a big heavy investment up front,” he continues. “So that’s one of the real differences between the two RFPs. The first one we’re saying we want to see everything you got, show us what you would recommend us to do. The second one we’re saying, this is the only kind of solution we’re going to consider.”
Despite Thibodeaux’s assertions, two vendors that have been involved in the bid process say they saw few differences in the two RFPs. A side-by-side comparison of the documents, which The Independent obtained through a public records request, reveals mostly technical changes. Both 18-page RFPs include many of the same safeguards against unforeseen expenses, including clauses that require “vendor maintenance plans have an all-inclusive ‘flat-fee’ that will not require LCG to pay any additional fees for changes, modifications, and updates requested throughout the year” and that “software installation must be an automated process that requires minimal I.T. involvement.” As for the project’s scope, the newer RFP actually states that LCG will be ordering more GPS tracking units than the first RFP (between 500 and 700 as opposed to the initial RFP’s 100 to 500 unit estimation).
Both RFPs also are full of esoteric specifications that those in the industry say are a red flag for a contract that is custom-built for a specific vendor. An example includes LCG’s request for polygon-shaped GEOfencing. While most vendors provide GEOfencing — a virtual fence set up to alert attendants to when a vehicle has moved outside a designated zone — a more select group designs them in polygon shapes. In addition, LCG stipulated that it wants its vendor to offer on-site support within two hours of a call — a clause that would seem to clearly favor a local business. “In matters involving public safety,” responds Thibodeaux, “it is imperative that a vehicle be returned to service in a prompt time frame. It is felt that the two-hour requirement is both reasonable and attainable.”
U.S. Fleet Tracking Corp is one national vendor that will no longer be bidding on the project. After submitting a proposal for the first RFP, U.S. Fleet’s National Sales Director Richard Banks says the company will not be participating in the second round of bids, having determined that the project’s specs will prohibit an out-of-state company from competing. It’s something Banks says unfortunately has become all too commonplace in the business.
“When you’re dealing with local governments,” he says, “and I don’t care if it’s Lafayette, or a city in Oklahoma or any other state — it’s not at all unusual to find an agency has already selected the vendor they want to use. They then write the bid specification for that specific product or vendor. We see this all the time.”
Banks adds that because of this, U.S. Fleet rarely bids on local government contracts anymore. Based in Oklahoma City, U.S. Fleet is one of the country’s largest GPS manufacturers, and this year will be tracking vehicles for events including the Super Bowl and the Winter Olympics in Vancouver. (The company also claims to be the only provider of real-time monitoring.)
“When we see cases where there’s odd or unusual language which favors a specific product, we decline to bid simply because we refuse to lend legitimacy to such corrupt bid processes and practices,” Banks says. “They may be issuing an RFP, but in reality they’re asking for a legitimate request from multiple vendors when there’s only one vendor that will meet 100 percent of the criteria they’ve laid out. Yes, it does happen. It happens all over the country. And it’s wrong.”
It’s a sentiment Doug Crawford with FAS Systems shares. His company will be bidding again on Lafayette’s GPS contract, but he isn’t holding out any hope of landing it. “Do I expect to get it?” he asks with a laugh. “Not a chance. I’d be willing to bet on that one. We can start an inner-office pool on it. That contract is going to someone in Acadiana.”
Law enforcement agencies are participating in a "Louisiana Heroin Summit," designed to address the recent rise in heroin use and drug-related deaths around the state.
State education officials are preparing to release performance scores for public schools and public school districts.
Saints coach Sean Payton is starting a new week by emphasizing, repeatedly, the many good things he noticed during New Orleans' latest loss.
Tuesday's Blogs from the Bog!
Oscar de la Renta dies; Pistorius sentenced; World Series begins and more national and international news for Tuesday, October 21, 2014.
We will be offering our recommendations on the constitutional amendments tomorrow.
The justices did not comment in leaving in place lower court rulings that dismissed the lawsuits against BP and other companies involved in the worst U.S. offshore oil spill.
White registration is down by 7,700 voters while black registration has shot up by 7,100 voters.
Even though it had been rumored for months, U.S. Sen. Mary Landrieu finally pulled the trigger recently on a major campaign shakeup that moved control over to a few Big Easy insiders.
Louisiana's health department says it will seek law changes to stop billing sexual assault victims for exams and tests.
It wasn’t the historic slashes to higher ed funding or the ensuing tuition spikes that recently had LSU’s student body and faculty riled up in collective outrage.
Will $400 be enough for the re-election campaign of LPSB's Hunter Beasley to overcome two years of holding our school system hostage and hurting the education of our children all because of a personal dislike of the superintendent?
Saints tight end Jimmy Graham said Friday he expects his playing status in Detroit to be decided by coach Sean Payton on Sunday, shortly before the game.
Lawmakers have sidestepped a decision on whether they accept claims from Gov. Bobby Jindal's administration that the state closed last year's books with a nearly $179 million surplus.
Coming off the high of a fourth quarter comeback against Tampa Bay and a helpful bye week, linebacker Junior Galette sees a real turnaround coming for New Orleans' struggling defense.
Former President Bill Clinton, the Democratic Party's most popular surrogate this fall, is heading to Louisiana early next week for a campaign rally with U.S. Sen. Mary Landrieu.
Time and again you hear people say DA Mike Harson is unbeatable because he's doled out political favors over the past 20 years. But a new lawsuit could end that speculation.
After the season's signature win (so far), here are some helpful tips for Cajun Nation during the conference stretch.
Did the state close last year's books with a surplus or a deficit?
Practicing without limitations on Wednesday, running back Mark Ingram looked ready to return to a New Orleans offense that once again ranks among the NFL's best when the Saints play at Detroit on Sunday.
It’s been decided: Superintendents of Louisiana’s public school system will retain the controversial powers granted by Act 1 of the 2012 session.
Louisiana Treasurer John Kennedy has a bone to pick with the Jindal administration, which recently — surprise! — announced that the state ended the most recent budget year with a $178.5 million dollar surplus.
The messaging battle, however, isn't tied to individual campaign accounts. Third-party groups have poured millions of dollars into advertising.
With her political future in jeopardy, Sen. Mary Landrieu is turning to a natural constituent base in her re-election bid.
Terrance Broadway threw for a touchdown and rushed for 113 yards to lead Louisiana-Lafayette to a 34-10 victory over Texas State on Tuesday night.