Wednesday, June 29, 2011
By Walter Pierce
A bill that would have created the Lafayette Parish Redevelopment Authority was opposed by both ends of the political spectrum.
The withdrawal of House Bill 531 on June 13 was an afterthought, really. The bill creating the Lafayette Parish Redevelopment Authority had cleared the state House on May 12 unanimously, enjoying the kind of overwhelming bipartisan support that most locally focused bills get. But before 531 was scheduled to move into a Senate committee on May 17, its sponsor, Rep. Joel Robideaux, an independent Lafayette lawmaker, pulled it from consideration. Not coincidentally, by that time howls of protest from the most far-flung political corners of Lafayette — the parish’s Democratic Executive Committee and the Tea Party of Lafayette — were reaching a crescendo. So, less than a month later when the bill limped out of the shadows to die, few were surprised and many were relieved.
Robideaux cited “important questions” and “unanswered concerns” about the proposed redevelopment authority in withdrawing the legislation, and in diagnosing the death of 531 those questions and concerns appear legitimate.
|House Bill 531 was written, supporters say, with abandoned, dilapidated properties like this in mind. Opponents of the bill warned it could lead to abuse of power by an unelected board.|
On its face 531 was well-intended — “to eliminate or prevent the development or spread of slums and blight, to encourage needed rehabilitation, to provide for the redevelopment of slums or blighted areas, and to undertake other feasible parochial activities as may be suitably employed to achieve the objectives of such workable program,” as the bill’s preamble reads. HB 531 was essentially a verbatim version of a 2007 bill that cleared the Legislature and was signed by Gov. Kathleen Blanco creating the East Baton Rouge Redevelopment Authority, substituting Lafayette for Baton Rouge.
The EBR Redevelopment Authority, or RDA as it’s known in the capital, began operations in 2008. High on its aggressive agenda are plans to redevelop five neighborhoods, most of them in north Baton Rouge’s decaying “inner city,” by acquiring blighted, tax-delinquent properties, clearing the titles and marketing those properties to individuals, developers and non-profits. While Baton Rouge’s RDA is just getting a head of steam, it was created and began operations in a different era — pre-tea party.
Like the RDA in Baton Rouge, Lafayette’s version would have been run by a five-person appointed board. Appointment power in the bill went to City-Parish President Joey Durel, the City-Parish Council, the Community Foundation of Acadiana, District 44 state Rep. Rickey Hardy and District 29 state Sen. Elbert Guillory. The latter two were granted appointment power, the bill reasoned, because their districts comprise the areas in Lafayette Parish most in need of redevelopment.
After 531 cleared the House, the ire of the Tea Party of Lafayette was fully stoked. “For shame Mr. Robideaux and all our House members for passing this deceitful legislation,” wrote Carol Ross to members of the Senate Local & Municipal Affairs Committee urging them to kill the bill. While not a listed member of TPL, Ross, wife of conservative newspaper publisher Ron Gomez and a frequent guest on Moon Griffon’s radio program, is certainly sympathetic with tea party issues.
Within days of Ross’ epistle to the Senate committee, the Lafayette Parish Democratic Executive Committee penned its own letter in opposition to 531 citing many of the same concerns.
Both parties’ objection to an appointed, un-elected commission are arguably tiresome to anyone familiar with Lafayette Parish governance: There are about three dozen such appointed boards and commissioners operating in Lafayette Parish. There’s the Airport Commission, the Library Board of Control, the Teche-Vermilion Fresh Water District and so on, all with devoted tax-revenue streams and many with the power to allocate taxpayer money. And they’ve been operating in Lafayette Parish for decades — above board, generally, but under the radar.
But elsewhere in 531 there are things that make you go hmmm. For example: “A bid by the authority at a tax sale for the minimum amount shall take priority over all other bids for the same quantity of property, except for a higher bid submitted by a conventional mortgage holder holding a mortgage on the subject property.”
Does that mean a higher bid for a tax-delinquent property by someone other than the mortgage holder would be trumped by a lower bid by the redevelopment authority? Apparently so.
HB 531 also grants the redevelopment authority the right to delineate “subdistricts” within the redevelopment district, which as the law is written would comprise all of Lafayette Parish unless one, some or all of the smaller municipalities wanted to opt out. And — here’s the rub for the tea party folks — “... a subdistrict may, within its geographical boundaries, utilize tax increment financing ...”
Those damn TIFs again!
So, while language in 531 specifically requires tax propositions supported by the redevelopment authority go to a vote of residents, the authority could potentially make an end run around that by designating subdistricts and creating those dreaded TIFs, which earned a black eye via the Glenn Stewart Parc Lafayette fiasco a few months ago.
| Council Chairman Kenneth Boudreaux was leery of the bill from the start.
And what, exactly, constitutes a “blighted” property?
When doing the autopsy on House Bill 531, maybe the biggest power broker in what transpired was City-Parish Council Chairman Kenneth Boudreaux, who represents District 4, the most economically distressed district in Lafayette Parish.
“We have always viewed the possession of land as the most valuable possession of any human being — the most valuable commodity there is,” Boudreaux says. “That’s all some people have is their family property. That’s why I didn’t want to move too fast on this — it’s huge. And all the negative things that have been said about this, I want to try to prevent those from happening as opposed to trying to fix them after they happen.”
Boudreaux felt slighted by the process that created the bill — especially so because as the councilman for a district that would be a focus of the authority’s mission he didn’t get a say in who served on the authority’s board of commissioners.
“I felt the appointments should be on a local level just as the city-parish president was a local appointment,” Boudreaux concedes. “And when you’re talking about self-governance, I felt it needs to be among the closest proximity of elected officials who work with these communities. Accountability’s going to be huge here in my opinion.”
After Robideaux initially pulled the bill, negotiations, if you can call them that, among the interested parties — particularly Boudreaux and the Durel administration — began. Durel agreed to a rewrite giving Boudreaux and District 3 Councilman Brandon Shelvin appointment power instead of state lawmakers Hardy and Guillory.
But ultimately they weren’t able to iron out other differences, mainly the possibility of this redevelopment authority being able to expropriate property, that is, declaring the acquisition of a title part of a “public necessity” or for “the greater good” and taking it against the title holder’s will. The bill is so meticulously crafted and so larded with lawyer dialect that it isn’t even clear if expropriation — “eminent domain” if you want to make it truly sinister — was even an option. But a source in the legal profession familiar with the bill says, yes, it is, “it’s a legitimate concern.” That same source also acknowledges the 500-pound gorilla in the room: A Lafayette Parish Redevelopment Authority, with an emphasis on “authority,” was seen in Lafayette’s black community as little more than an attempt by “the white man” to snatch black property — a view underscored by the bill’s provenance: white Republican Joey Durel.
|City-Parish President Joey Durel was frustrated by the derailing of HB 531.|
As 531 derailed, Durel found himself in an awkward position, pushed from the right by the tea party, from the left by the Dems and from the center by the council chairman. The city-parish president declined comment for this story, but another source tells The Ind he was and remains angry and frustrated by what happened, and feels that a bill with good intentions was sabotaged by representatives — Boudreaux especially and local Democrats generally — of the people 531 was intended to help.
Durel, we’re also told, is ready to wash his hands of the issue and isn’t likely to back such legislation in the future.
The Chamber's Empower PAC is throwing its support behind Justin Centanni in his bid for the District 6 seat on the LPSB.
One day after a Lafayette Parish judge declared Louisiana's ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional, the state's top lawyer announced plans to challenge that decision before the Supreme Court of Louisiana.
Photos of a vulnerable Democratic senator helping a constituent drink upside-down from a beer keg would be a faux pas six weeks before Election Day in many places.
Greenstein is accused of lying under oath in testimony about his role in the awarding of a $200 million state contract to his former employer, CNSI, to provide Medicaid billing and fraud oversight services.
The New Orleans Saints are taking a critical look at their first victory of the season.
Candidates running for districts 1, 2 and 3 of the school board will kick-off the first of a three night series of forums at the LITE Center.
The Louisiana Democratic Party may have endorsed former Gov. Edwin Edwards for Congress, but the state's highest elected Democratic official won't be doing the same.
Rights of same-sex military families vary; airstrikes begin against ISIS; WHO warns about Ebola and more national and international news for Tuesday, September 23, 2014.
Tuesday's Blogs from the Bog!
The city-parish president formed a company in early August, Durel Properties LLC, and has a buy/sell agreement for his first office building.
Numerous local media outlets are reporting that State District Judge Ed Rubin has ruled unconstitutional the state’s ban on same-sex marriage.
With the turmoil raging and our school system continuing to hold on by a thread in anticipation of November’s elections, several Acadiana’s legislators are throwing their names and their support behind the candidates: Most recently with an endorsement of Jeremy Hidalgo's campaign for District 9.
Questions about the dispute over the Common Core education standards, or still wondering what the standards even are?
After failing to pass reform legislation aimed at the payday loan industry last year, Sen. Ben Nevers, D-Bogalusa, said he is considering bringing a bill again but is still on the fence.
More than 100 candidates either withdrew from their races or were disqualified since the mail ballots were printed following the August qualifying period.
For Dudley Nelson, a 2011 hit on a truck stop casino netted him and two friends $11,675 in stolen cash, as well as a 105 month stay in prison following a federal sentencing hearing held Friday for the 25-year-old Ville Platte man.
The Louisiana Hospital Association, Louisiana Nursing Home Association, Louisiana Pharmacists Association, ambulance providers and intermediate care facilities are pooling their resources and planning for a statewide media buy to promote the passage of the first two constitutional amendments on the November ballot.
Kelly McAllister, wife of the congressman from Louisiana's 5th District, will address her husband's infidelity for the first time in a campaign ad that will begin airing today, reports LaPolitics.
A suspenseful election night is one thing, but what if it stretches out for a month? Or into next year?
The Saints' defense was starting to look like a liability in coordinator Rob Ryan's second season.
Questions about the dispute over the Common Core education standards, or still wondering what the standards even are?
Disappointed in the way he played a week ago, Boise State running back Jay Ajayi said he was determined to do more to help the Broncos win this week.
Despite sweeping changes enacted by Gov. Bobby Jindal's administration, the health insurance program for state workers and public school employees will have to use $88 million from its reserve fund to cover its costs this year.
The LPSB races are sure to get heated between now and Nov. 4, and with only 9 available seats, this year's field of 20 candidates will surely be wanting to set themselves apart from the crowd early; they'll get their chance next week, starting Tuesday with the kick-off of a three-day series of candidate forums.
Lawmakers say they've received complaints that waits have spiked, with people being forced to wait in line for more than an hour — and sometimes three hours — to handle routine tasks.