Coastal restoration advocates are up in arms over an amendment inserted into a bill that would direct fines paid by BP and other companies linked to the 2010 Deepwater Horizon spill to the state’s Coastal Protection and Restoration Fund. House Bill 812 by Rep. Simone Champagne, R-Jeanerette, was amended Tuesday by the Senate Finance Committee to allow state lawmakers to siphon off the penalty money for virtually anything, provided that diversion of cash is approved by two thirds of each chamber of the Legislature:
The legislature, by a favorable vote of two-thirds of the elected members of each house, may authorize the expenditures of monies received by the state under the provisions of this paragraph for any purposes not prohibited by this constitution or by Congress. Any such authorization shall be approved by passage of a specific legislative instrument which clearly states the purposes for which the monies will be expended.
The bill as amended is before the full Senate, and opponents of the amendment argue it sends the wrong message to the U.S. Congress, which is reportedly close to passing the RESTORE Act, a bill that would send 80 percent of any Clean Water Act fines levied for the BP spill to the five Gulf Coast states.
On Thursday Blueprint Louisiana, a statewide good-government group comprising civic and business leaders, chimed its concern with the amendment:
While Blueprint is on record for supporting budget flexibility measures allowed by current state law, there are limited circumstances when a dedication is necessary. The Deepwater Horizon incident is one such instance, where the impact was on the coast and where we must demonstrate our commitment to restoration in order to maximize the benefit to Louisiana. The language of the Congressional RESTORE Act dedicates fines from BP and other responsible parties to coastal restoration. We should honor Congress’ wishes as well as our commitment to Louisiana’s coastal communities to ensure that this money is used to rebuild our coast.
We now have a comprehensive master plan for our coast. Let’s show the rest of the nation we can deliver on that plan with money resulting from any environmental fines and violations from the Deepwater Horizon incident. Thank you for your service.
Chris Macaluso, coastal outreach coordinator for the Louisiana Wildlife Federation, issued a press release following the Senate Finance action urging lawmakers to rethink the amendment:
It essentially derails the intent of the legislation...
This amendment sends absolutely the wrong message to Congress, particularly at a time when the RESTORE Act is being considered and is so close to passage. Louisiana’s message to Congress needs to be clear and specific that Clean Water Act penalty money will be spent on coastal restoration and on nothing else. In my extensive talks with congressmen and congressional staff regarding RESTORE, the biggest concern about passing such a powerful piece of legislation was mistrust that Louisiana’s Legislature would do the right thing with the money.
This amendment, to what is otherwise a very good piece of legislation and a good constitutional amendment, confirms those fears. Some legislators want to get their hands on this money and spend it on whatever whim or budget hole that needs to be filled.
To post a comment, please log into your IND account. If you do not have an account, click the "register" button to create one. Facebook comments can be used as an alternative to creating an account at theIND.com.
DEC 18 Here's a story in Newsweek about the Bayou Corne sinkhole (warning: autoplay video here). It is a long, detailed, very comprehensive story. It's definitely more comprehensive than the local media coverage to date. There's a lot of information about the sinkhole (new information, really) but there's also a look at the phenomenon of "Cancer Alley."
DEC 18 A recent poll of possible gubernatorial candidates has Sen. David Vitter in the lead, Jeremy Alford writes on LaPolitics. He's polling at 25 percent, followed by Mitch Landrieu at 20 percent and Jay Dardenne at 12 percent. Here's what Jeremy didn't address: did Vitter interrupt his prayerful consideration to look at these results? The world may never know. Here's something else, that we will know, eventually: how soon before the first commercial mentioning the unmentionable airs?
DEC 18 Blogger Robert Mann has some advice for Governor Jindal: take your own. Mann pulls out some 2008 quotes from the governor on health care for the poor and contrasts them against the governor's more recent actions (or inaction) in the same arena. Part of the plan? Expand Medicaid. Wait -- what??
DEC 18 Here's a sweet post on Gambit by Ken Bode about the passing of George Rodrigue. Bode met the artist 30 years ago, and has a lot of funny stories about his friend. One of the best is how much George laughed over learning that President Clinton re-gifted a set of Blue Dog earrings -- to Ken Starr. The portrait Bode paints here is one of a man who loved life, and was constantly reminding the rest of us that we should, too.
DEC 18 Conservative blogger Rod Dreher doesn't usually agree with The Advocate (the national publication, which is the largest gay magazine in the country) but in this post he does. The Advocate, like Time, has named Pope Francis its person of the year. Punctuating that are some recent moves the Pontiff has made, including the removal of a vocally anti-gay Bishop from a position of power. As usual, Dreher gives us a lot of information and raises questions, encouraging readers to think it over. But he does agree with the Advocate's selection, calling it "a savvy choice."
DEC 18 Ever since a recall election put an end to the ongoing Deedy vs. Hootie saga over in Port Allen, the City Council has been working hard to prove all the problems didn't rest with former mayor, Deedy Slaughter, by failing to appoint her temporary replacement. Gov. Jindal was stuck with the job, so he picked a former mayor to take over the reins. Let's hope that lady is eating her Wheaties; she's gonna need the energy.
DEC 18 Blogger Tom Aswell seems to hear all the good rumors, and this one is a really good one: there's a plan to get Sen. David Vitter elected governor and then appoint Gov. Bobby Jindal to serve out the last year of Vitter's Senate term. Hey, that's a great idea, and if there's anything Bobby has made clear, it's that he would prefer to live in DC anyway.
DEC 18 If a Reveillion Dinner is part of your holiday tradition, this post in NOLA Defender is for you. The blog gives a list, including menus, of some of the best ones in the city. They've even got prices and numbers to call to make reservations.
Read the Flipping Paper!
Click Here for the Entire Print Version of IND Monthly