[Editor's Note: This story has been altered to include a statement from Acadian. The story initially indicated that Acadian did not respond to a request for comment. An email seeking comment never reached Acadian because we used an incorrect address.]
In 2010, then seven-months pregnant, Whitley Lacey of Plaquemine phoned Acadian Ambulance when she began having stomach pains. Then 21 years old and the mother of a small child, Whitley Lacey would never be the same.
The driver of the ambulance, Michael Averrette, upon realizing he had not logged into his GPS driver-monitoring device, according to plaintiff attorney William Gee, reached in his pocket to get the keys and dropped them on the floorboard. “[He] took his eyes off the road and crashed into the back of a sugar cane truck,” says Gee, who represents Whitley’s family. The accident left Whitley a triplegic and brain damaged; her baby was delivered by C-section while Whitley was in a coma. To this day, Whitley remains hospitalized, is bound to a wheelchair for life and will need 24-hour care for the rest of her life, Gee says.
Her mother, Peggy Ross, sued on behalf of her daughter and grandchildren. On Wednesday, an Iberville Parish jury handed down a $117 million award against Acadian Ambulance, all for compensatory damages. “The award was almost what we were asking the jury [for],” Gee says.
The largest amount, $35 million, is for Whitley’s future medical and life care expenses. The jury also awarded her $20 million for future physical pain and suffering and mental anguish and $20 million for future loss of enjoyment of life. Another $15 million is for past physical pain and suffering and mental anguish. Her two daughters, Aaliyaha and Z'kyriah Lacey, were each awarded $2.5 million for loss of consortium.
“As a result of this violent and devastating collision, Whitley will never be the same,” Gee says.
Acadian’s general counsel, Allyson Pharr, says the company will appeal. She released the following statement to The Independent today:
This was a horrible tragedy and our hearts and prayers remain with Ms. Lacey and her family. While it is extremely difficult to put a value on a case such as this or ponder the fairness of an award amount, we do hope that the damage amount ultimately awarded will be used to provide Ms. Lacey with quality care and ensure that her children will not forego any opportunities that they may otherwise have had were it not for the injuries their mother sustained in this accident.
Acadian’s ambulances are driven over 26 million miles annually. We take driving safety very seriously. Among other daily measures, our employees undergo extensive initial driver training and annual refresher training. We equip our units with GPS devices and accelerometers that measure driving behavior and offer audible feedback to our crews. Unfortunately, even despite all of these proactive safety measures, accidents do occur. In addition to fully investigating and taking any remedial and/or educational and training steps to address any behaviors that may contribute to these situations, we also stand and are accountable, taking full responsibility to the extent our actions or those of our employees contribute to the damages sustained by persons such as Ms. Lacey.
It is more difficult to get compensatory damages reduced, says Lafayette attorney Richard Broussard, who was not involved in the case. “You don’t have that enhanced scrutiny that you have with punitive damages. I would say that without researching several of the general damage awards, which is non-economic awards, several of those are well outside of what has been awarded in the past for similar tragedies.” Those are the ones more likely to be addressed on appeal, adds Broussard, who has almost four decades of experience representing plaintiffs in personal injury cases. Non-economic damages include past and future physical pain and suffering, past and future loss of enjoyment of life, scarring and disfigurement, and loss of consortium.
Each case, however, is different, Broussard maintains. “There may have been something about what these kids are going through or what this lady is going through that is so far outside the range of normal that it’s justified to have a much higher than normal award,” he suggests.
“Any reader is likely to gasp at the size of the award, but until you personally see what someone goes through with this kind of injury, you can’t appreciate how normal people would want to compensate the injury. It’s easy to say, ‘Wow, the jury really put out some money here,’ but if you’re sitting where they sat and watched the evidence come through you can probably understand better how they reached this award.”
JUNE 19 Former Saint Steve Gleason, who is paralyzed by ALS, released a statement Tuesday in response to the Atlanta radio station's skit making fun of him and the disease, this Picayune post reports. What did he say? He said he'd accepted the apology of the DJs who did it, notes that at least the incident has got people talking about ALS, and asks anyone who is burning to take action about it to do so -- by helping him fight ALS.
JUNE 19 Blogger Ian McGibboney takes a look at the Gleason incident in this post. He makes a good argument about the difference between having free speech and being free from consequences for your speech (which none of us is). He also admits that many of us got upset before we listened to the skit -- but lets us know that the reality is far worse than we can imagine. It was the incredibly bad judgment, even more than the actual speech, that probably got those DJs fired, he opines.
JUNE 19 Washington Post blogger Aaron Blake writes about Sen. Guillory's switch to the GOP in this post. He writes what most political watchers in Louisiana know: Guillory was a Republican before he decided to run for the senate seat in a mostly-D St. Landry district, and has switched back now that he plans to run for Lt. Gov. in a mostly-R state. But how come Blake missed Guillory's appearance on a TLC pageant show? Now that is a video we'd like to see. (Again).
JUNE 19 Here's another Washington Post blog post about a Louisiana politician, and it's just plain scathing. Ezra Klein says Jindal's Politico post was "insulting" to the intelligence of voters, and adds that Jindal is personifying the "stupid" he's railed against, by being an "elite" who convinces GOP activists of "things that aren't true." Me-ow.
JUNE 19 Here's Gov. Jindal's post in Politico, in which he asks the GOP to get over losing to Obama (again) and stop "the bedwetting." (Uh, what?) He gives his Republican buddies what is probably a nerd's idea of a coach's motivational talk, which starts with a list of accomplishments that they can't seem to exploit and ending with an absurd description of liberals that sounds like a character treatment for a Fox "News" movie scripted by Gordon Liddy. Sure, he's preaching to the choir, but even the choir's not this gullible.
JUNE 19 Lamar Parmentel read Gov. Jindal's post on Politico, but thinks it was so dumb it probably was published in the wrong paper. This post by Lamar on the Daily Kingfish opines that possibly Jindal's post was destined for the Onion -- because the governor couldn't possibly be serious here. If you listen closely, you can hear the staff of the Kingfish giggling.
JUNE 19 Blogger Robert Mann posts from Turkey, a country he has visited several times in the past few years. Mann gives an interesting overview of the current political and societal climate of the country, which -- if you're living under a rock and don't know -- is experiencing protests and turmoil these days. Mann promises to post as much as he can during his trip, which should be fascinating reading.
JUNE 19 Blogger CB Forgotston says the legislature is keeping the vicious cycle going with its funding of new buildings for the community college/technical college system. Universities across the state need maintenance and improvement on existing buildings, and the solution is to build new buildings at other schools? By the time the bonds are paid off, those buildings will be falling down, too, CB says.
Most Read
in case you missed it
Subscribe to this comment's feed