Appeals court strikes down state’s 'Driving While Hispanic' law
Citing a U.S. Supreme Court decision voiding a similar law passed in Arizona, the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeal struck down a Louisiana statute known as the “Driving Without Lawful Presence” law — one derided by critics as the “Driving While Hispanic” law.
The challenge to the law, known officially as Louisiana Revised Statute 14:100.13, was made by an attorney in the 15th Judicial District Public Defender’s Office on behalf of a Honduran man who was arrested in Lafayette, jailed for three months awaiting trial and eventually pleaded no contest to violating the law. District Judge Kristian Earles presided over adjudication of the case against Alexis Sarrabea.
The law in question states:
A. No alien student or nonresident alien shall operate a motor vehicle in the state without documentation demonstrating that the person is lawfully present in the United States.
B. Upon arrest of a person for operating a vehicle without lawful presence in the United States, law enforcement officials shall seize the driver’s license and immediately surrender such license to the office of motor vehicles for cancellation and shall immediately notify the INS of the name and location of the person.
C. Whoever commits the crime of driving without lawful presence in the United States shall be fined not more than one thousand dollars, imprisoned for not more than one year, with or without hard labor, or both.
The 3rd Circuit effectively voided the state law through Wednesday’s ruling, pending an appeal to the Louisiana Supreme Court. In its decision the 3rd Circuit writes:
We believe Defendant’s focus on the Supreme Court‘s ruling in Arizona regarding section 3 of the Arizona law is well-placed. We could find no reported Louisiana cases addressing the constitutionality of La.R.S. 14:100.13 since the ruling in Arizona. ...
Moreover, La.R.S. 14:100.13 offers no definition of the terms ? “alien student” or “non resident alien.” These terms have no real meaning under the federal immigration scheme and are not recognized in federal immigration provisions. Neither does the statute define what is meant by “lawfully present in the United States.”...
To put it plain and simple, La.R.S. 14:10 0.13 is preempted by federal law; and the State of Louisiana lacks Constitutional authority to enforce it. Defendant‘s conviction and sentence are reversed and set aside.
Lafayette attorney G. Paul Marx, who runs the 15th JDC Public Defender’s Office, hailed the ruling in a statement released Wednesday morning:
Louisiana should focus on arrests of serious offenses which ICE will use for deportation, instead of a half baked attempt to regulate illegal immigration that is error prone and wasteful. Two courts have now found that the Louisiana Law is invalid since Arizona v U.S. was handed down.
This state does not have the resources to waste jail space and manpower on this traffic type statute when serious offenders who are illegal aliens can be shipped out by the federal government. Currently, arrests under this statute hold people for a few weeks or months, and ICE has no interest unless there is a felony offense: this statute is not working unless draining resources from law enforcement was the goal. The Third Circuit has made the correct call.
To post a comment, please log into your IND account. If you do not have an account, click the "register" button to create one. Facebook comments can be used as an alternative to creating an account at theIND.com.
DEC 11 It's the holiday season, and that means you can count on seeing some pretty crazy stuff going down at the Wal-Mart, but this story out of Marshall, Texas takes the cake. A man went in and attacked a couple of people with a hatchet. Who stopped him? A customer who started launching soup cans at him -- and connected with his noggin. The story tells us that while some folk were injured, everyone's been released from the hospital.
DEC 11 Blogger Tom Aswell joins the ranks of those looking into the "Fund for Louisiana's Future," which of course is not really aimed at improving our future. So far, it seems aimed at getting Louisiana to remove its $100,000 cap on campaign contributions, he tells us. Also, it is overseen by the same guy who tried to give us President Mitt Romney -- and he seems bent on picking our next governor.
DEC 11 Here's a post on NOLA Defender from the chef de cuisine at Delmonico's about gumbo. Chef Anthony Scanio shares childhood food memories that aren't quite a warm and fuzzy cliche -- but they certainly sound authentic. His personal story isn't just about food, it's a true New Orleans boy's upbringing. It's a cool story, and it ends with recipes for seafood gumbo and red beans.
DEC 11 Blogger Lou Gehrig Burnett writes here on Bayou Buzz about GOP efforts to mount a candidate against Sen. Mary Landrieu -- "a" being the operative word. So far, Bill Cassidy and Rob Maness are both in the race, and as long as the ultra-conservative Maness remains he poses a threat to the Republicans' hopes to unseat Mary. There's also a bit on what's up in Texas -- where Gov. Rick Perry's rejection of Medicaid money is causing other lawmakers some trouble.
DEC 11 Qualifying for New Orleans municipal races opens today, and Gambit's Clancy DuBos is most interested in people running against Sheriff Marlin Gusman, a frequent topic of Clancy's posts -- and a lot of other media posts as well. So far, the most interesting candidate expected to qualify is former sheriff Charles Foti. But Gusman's biggest enemy may be himself, given his 33 percent approval rating.
DEC 11 It may be the season of brotherly love, but John Maginnis is not falling for David Vitter's Christmas story. In this post, he poo-poos the very idea that Vitter and his family will spend the holidays in prayerful reflection so that they can decide if the Senator will run for governor. He also gives some predictions on what could happen if Vitter did get elected, throwing in a cautionary reference to the big ole egg laid by the GOP up in North Louisiana's recent Congressional race.
DEC 11 Well, knock us over with a rainbow-colored feather. The Shreveport City Council passed an ordinance granting equal protection to LGBT folks, this KSLA story reports. It basically forbids discrimination against people based on their sexual orientation. According to the story, city workers already have had that protection, since 2009.
DEC 11 That nice lady over in Denham Springs must still be mad at her neighbors for stealing her dog, because she's back up on her roof, making a big ole "one finger salute" in Christmas lights. This story in the Advocate even gives us a picture of the process underway, in case you are experiencing a similar situation and would like some finger-display-creation tips.
Read the Flipping Paper!
Click Here for the Entire Print Version of IND Monthly