News -> INDReporter FRI, JUN 18 10:43AM by Walter Pierce

Melancon slams Barton; Boustany quiet

Acadiana’s members of the U.S. House of Representatives are reflecting party affiliation in their reaction to fellow Congressman Joe Barton’s much-talked-about apology to BP CEO Tony Hayward. While fellow Republican Rep. Charles Boustany of Lafayette has remained quiet about the Texan’s comments, within hours of the flap U.S. Rep. Charlie Melancon, D-Napoleonville, joined a howling chorus of fellow Democrats in condemning Barton’s remarks:
Joe Barton’s apology to BP is offensive to the thousands of Louisianians whose entire future has been jeopardized by the oil disaster. From fishermen to shrimpers to oil and gas workers, BP’s irresponsibility has put the livelihoods of thousands at risk. I make no apologies for holding BP 100 percent accountable for their negligence. If Joe Barton wants to apologize to someone, I suggest he apologize to the people of Louisiana for his insensitive comments.

Barton, the ranking Republican member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, on Thursday told Hayward he was “ashamed” of the “$20 billion shakedown” of the oil company, referring to BP’s agreement with the Obama administration to create a $20 billion escrow fund from which a third-party administrator will draw compensation payments for victims of the Gulf oil disaster. The language in Barton’s rhetoric was evidently lifted from talking points in a press release issued hours earlier by the Republican Study Committee, an influential conservative caucus to which the majority of GOP Congress members belong. That RSC release referred to the escrow agreement as “Chicago-style shakedown politics.”

Barton later retracted the apology after House Minority Leader John Boehner and other GOP leadership threatened to strip him of his Energy Committee leadership post.

 


Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (25)add
...
written by rocknwroll , June 18, 2010 - 10:54 am
Barton's initial comments typify in general the Republican party mindset toward the average American (corporations 1st, people 2nd or maybe a distant 4th behind dogs and cats). Think about it next time you vote.
...
written by Ragin Cajun , June 18, 2010 - 12:15 pm
great article, ha. melancon is in a heated senate race. focus on cleaning the damn mess up and ignore a rep from texas.
...
written by Lloyd Rochon , June 18, 2010 - 12:32 pm
It may not be a shakedown, but it certainly is bad policy. What will happen in the future when an American company is in a similar position of BP. Do we not understand that we are needlessly placing a potential burden on these companys? Obama's reaction to creat a 20 Billion dollar escrow account is pure politices because it sounds good. Buddy you can be sure that I will think about it when I vote. I think a few others will also-but not the way you want is to.
...
written by Cajun Man , June 18, 2010 - 03:23 pm
Rocknwroll, you got it right.

20 B escrow fund is a good move, considering BP's road to being bankrupt

...
written by J. P. Stoshak , June 18, 2010 - 03:53 pm
Lloyd Rochon would do well to realize that any corporate entity must be held accountable, whatever their national origin, for atrocities inflicted on the prolitariate anywhere in the world. After all that the people of our gulf region have weathered, it is quite crude to refer to tough measures on their behalf as a "shakedown." As for "bad policy," again, any measure that aides, assists, or funds the people who are traumatized by this debacle is a deed well done.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , June 19, 2010 - 12:06 am
Lloyd Rochon as usual doing what he does best geneflecting and kissing where the sun doesn't shine.........Always playing the political game with his hat in his hand, and waiting for a crumb from whomever will be doing the handouts. Rest assured Reverend Rochon will survive at the head of the line, Louisiana's, own Jesse Jackson, never has met a Bossman he did'nt like, do your tap dance Lil Lloyd .
...
written by ragin_cajun , June 20, 2010 - 09:13 am
"prolitariate"--What kind of leftist are you? You can't even SPELL proletariat. So concerned about the working class and the marxist solution to their "struggle" that you've never even bothered to read enough to remember how to properly spell the word.




...
written by Plumpy , June 20, 2010 - 02:10 pm
rocknwroll...democrat party has been taken over by liberal socialists..I like to call'em..Communists..I'm still going to vote Republican even though i'm a Independent..at least republicans haven't turned into communists ..
...
written by HARDHAT , June 20, 2010 - 08:12 pm
YEP YEP, The Democrats do everyone and the Republicans single out the middle class. There are not any poverty-level Republicans, if there are any, i've never met them. THey know they can't squeeze anything out of the wealthy, and the poverty peeps have not anything to take away, so guess who gets Bourre'd.
YEP! The middle working class, " a dying breed!
With all the peeps on government assistance, and the Baby-Mama's
dropping em as though, they are gettin paid to have em.
The only way to get a good scratch is to do the middle class !
Republicans bleed RED WHITE and BLUE... "THE GREATEST CAPITALIST GOD EVER PUT ON THIS EARTH, and they hate Communism, for they know they could'nt survive in a communist state, they'd be lashed and hung out to dry, for robbing the Communist Party !
...
written by Hugh Robertson , June 21, 2010 - 06:34 am
To those who think the $20b fund is a bad idea, what would you like Obama to do? Let BP just go on as business as usual as if nothing has happened? "OH, we know you're sorry for the 'mistakes' you've made, but we understand, stuff happens, don't worry about it, just do the best you can." Right. It's pretty clear that BP was engaging in reckless endangerment on a mass scale. Last year when the Obama admin made some noises about tightening up regulations all the oil suckups were complaining about stifling the industry and now that something has happened Obama is to blame? Get real.
...
written by Bayou Self , June 21, 2010 - 06:49 am
What if a foreign-based corporation in your own town caused an oil spill all over your own neighborhood, including your house, killing all the grass and landscaping and making it impossible for anything to grow there for years? What if this corporation made incredible profits from your town's natural resources, but had not invested in safety precautions that may have prevented this? What if your kids were getting sick from the fumes? Would you want to be on your own to deal with it, or would you expect your mayor or governor to force the company to clean up the mess they caused and reimburse you for the expenses you incurred because of their incident?
...
written by Resident , June 21, 2010 - 07:14 am
So Stoshak is a "leftist" for saying that BP must be held accountable and it's good to set up a fund to assist the people devastated by this event? Maybe you were too quick to go into the talking point cliches this time? Plumpy still has you beat for the amount of empty rhetoric per paragraph.

It's downright laughable seeing the partisans taking Barton's side because he's a Republican criticizing Obama. The same people who just last week were criticizing Obama for not doing enough and not meeting with BP CEOs are now criticizing him for meeting with BP CEOs and getting them to set up a fund for damages. Amazing.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , June 21, 2010 - 02:08 pm
" YOU ARE SO IN TUNE WITH REALITY, MR. ROBERTSON " Obama is doing his damnest to save the Democratic Party, which blew the most insurmountable odds against the Republicans coming thru the gate next election, bringing it all to a dead heat race, all because Obama has let Big Money slide and Madoff BUYING SCORES OF fIGHTER JETS AND ROCKETS FOR ISRAEL, and STANFORD financing the DEMOS NEXT ELECTION......YOU HEARD IT HERE !
...
written by EXISTENTIALIST HOMME , June 21, 2010 - 02:28 pm
Please inform me and the general public, just who is this LLOYD RACHON, What is his occupation ? I demand to know, why he is walking around the populace, unrestraint !
...
written by ragin_cajun , June 21, 2010 - 03:54 pm
Resident--

No, Stoshak is a leftist for using terms like "prolitariate" to refer to people, and he's an illiterate for misspelling the word.

For the record, I am not the same "Ragin Cajun" that posted on June 18. Also for the record, I agree that BP should pay for damages that it has caused--basic property rights in a capitalist society MUST be protected in every instance. I even think that the escrow account is a good idea, assuming the "third party" that is managing the fund is reliable and honest. The government can't be trusted to hold money, and BP can't be trusted to fairly dispense it.
...
written by HARDHAT , June 21, 2010 - 09:58 pm
Stoshack is an antagnostic problematic puto !
...
written by What, me worry? , June 22, 2010 - 03:13 am
To dwell on a misspelled word and to refer to someone as illiterate because of a typo shows no intelligence whatsoever. The term proletariat does not signify leftist simply due to its use. That is a rather stupid call as well in that the poster had to make sure that his lack of depth is noticed. He posted the same item theme in this second post. redudancy is a sign of not being taken seriously. It is easy to understand why he is ragin'.
...
written by J. P. Stoshak , June 22, 2010 - 05:28 am
Such furor over a misspelled word, proletariat, that simply means working class. Who'd a ever thunk it? Bottom line is that any corporate entity must be held accountable, whatever their national origin, for atrocities inflicted on the working class and all classes of people anywhere in the world. Misspelled words and/or misused phrases are kinda Yogi Berra-esque, "You know what he means." No nom de plume here. I signed my name.
...
written by ragin_cajun , June 22, 2010 - 10:39 am
Yeah, just writing "prolitariate" does not make you a leftist. However, writing " atrocities inflicted on the prolitariate anywhere in the world" does. Read just a little Trotsky, and you'd recognize the writing style--the exaggeration, the term proletariat, and then the global perspective, it just encapsulates the Bolshevik rallying cry in a very concise way.

The reason why I mentioned it twice, is because Resident posed a question about the post. He wrote "So Stoshak is a "leftist" for saying that BP must be held accountable and ..." and ended the sentence with a question. So I answered him.
...
written by J. P. Stoshak , June 22, 2010 - 11:03 am
Though I've read Trotsky, the term is attributed to Karl Marx through "The Communist Manifesto." Also, it is your anonymous unlearned perception as to what the term conveys. If you choose to read so much into my usage of the word, then it is you who have the problem. Not to mention that you do not possess the courage of your convictions. Hence, you do not sign you name. Again, ignorance is a good reason to rage.
...
written by ragin_cajun , June 22, 2010 - 01:52 pm
Stoshak--

"unlearned"? "ignorant"? What ME? YOU'RE the one who started this with your atrocious spelling and leftist drivel.

Like I already said it's not the term, it's the phrase AND the term together that remind me so much of the Bolsheviks.

But it's alright! You're not a socialist, OK? My mistake. You just talk like one sometimes :)
...
written by Walter Pierce, Managing Editor , June 22, 2010 - 02:03 pm
OK ragin_cajun and J.P., back behind your lines. I'm encamping in your Balkans and imposing a cease-fire.
...
written by Resident , June 22, 2010 - 04:00 pm
J.P., you said "furor" which is too close to "fuhrer." I think it was a Freudian misspell. You must be a Hitler protege, a Nazi sympathizer and therefore an Obama lover because Obama is a secret Marxist which is really just a socialist, and socialism is communism and communism is just like Nazism which is really just Marxism. Anyway.....you're a leftist socialist communist Marxist Nazi.
...
written by ragin_cajun , June 22, 2010 - 05:08 pm
there is nothing secret about Obama's marxism.
...
written by Jason D. Faulk , June 28, 2010 - 02:44 am
If you all would like a list of Communist parties in the USA, go here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C...ed_States

Last I checked, American Democrats (emphasis on the capitalized D) don't seem to match up to the ideas of revolutionary or institutional Communism. They are more likely to be regarded applying some aspects of Social Democracy ever since the 1920's and Huey Long here in Louisiana (perhaps earlier in other parts of the country, depending on the social movements unique to the varying regions of the US.

Some posters on this board that also criticize government initiated electrical, water, sewerage and telecommunications services throughout the 19th, 20th and 21st centuries, along with public education, would probably criticize the State Bank of North Dakota for being a sign of despotic, tyrannical big government rule of the libertarian individualistic masses. That bank managed to form 100+ years ago when the NY and Chicago bankers were screwing over farmers of N. Dakota. That bank now helped buffer their state from the insanity, yes, insanity of the housing bubble meets securitization of the CDO/CDS nonsense that tanked our economy and nearly crashed our system 2 years ago.

So at any rate, glad to hear that at least one of the two coastal congress representatives had a response to Joe Barton. The Oil companies might invest in the extraction of resources, but ultimately they are the people's resources, held in trust by our state and our federal government. These resources cannot be recreated once mined and burned, wise use is necessary, and setting a wise energy policy along with damage containment and mitigation policies independent of those producing is crucial, not least of which is necessity to have INDEPENDENT CONGRESSMEN who are not shills for any one sector or capital interest group.

Long Live the Corporations, God Save the BP..... NOT
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
LA LA Land
Advertisement
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it