News -> INDReporter MON, FEB 7 11:16AM by Walter Pierce

Chamber softens position on scorecard

The Greater Lafayette Chamber of Commerce is in damage-control mode, evidenced by a letter to the editor and series of articles and editorials published Sunday in The Daily Advertiser in which the chamber both defends the legislative scorecard it released in January while softening its stand on the failing grade handed out to state Sen. Mike Michot.

Chamber leadership emailed the same statement to The Independent on Sunday — the same day the articles and editorials appeared in The Advertiser. Conspicuously absent from that Advertiser coverage were any quotes from Michot, who acknowledged to The Ind last week that he did indeed meet with chamber leadership but declined their offer to make the letter to the editor a joint statement.

20110126-ABIZcover-0101
     State Sen. Mike Michot, R-Lafayette
The senator, in the final furlong of his time in office — he is term limited and will be replaced by an election this fall — is still smarting from the failing grade he was given by the chamber on its scorecard. Our reading is that Michot is more angry than disappointed, as he — like many in the community — believes he has been a steady advocate of Lafayette’s business interests during his 16 years in the Legislature. (Michot’s failing grade stemmed more from his absence at four of the 12 votes on which senators were graded by the chamber — votes Michot says he missed while tending to other important business in his role as chairman of the Senate Finance Committee. The chamber acknowledges in the letter reprinted below that it is reviewing how absences weigh into grades.) Michot maintains that the grades distributed by the chamber were counterproductive to the longtime goal of knitting a strong coalition of Acadiana lawmakers to work in unison for the business interests in the area.

Here’s the chamber’s letter:
In 2010, the Greater Lafayette Chamber of Commerce took a bold step in its long history of representing the interest of business. That step, as recommended by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, was the issuance of a voting record of local elected officials. The voting record report is a resource for the Chamber’s newly formed political action committee.

However, the simple idea of reporting on voting records brings with it the inherent risk of appearing to disapprove of a candidate or candidates, or having the report record being interpreted incorrectly. The Chamber, in reporting on voting records, provides numerical scores and not letter scores.

Unfortunately, as in the case of Lafayette Senator Mike Michot, the reported voting record tallied absences from significant votes due to his demanding and important role as Chairman of the Finance Committee. Thus, the unintended consequences were that a proven friend of the chamber and community received a low numerical score, which mischaracterizes Senator Michot’s legislative contribution.

Recognizing that the voting record, which is based on actual votes, did not accurately account for a pro-business philosophy, or an entire body of work, the chamber will modify its initial protocol. The Chamber will continue to communicate its positions on behalf of its members, will continue to monitor lawmakers’ votes, and will continue to hold them accountable.

The goal is to enhance the critical business infrastructure and environment for small and large businesses. That end will be achieved through positive, collaborative spirit by the Chamber, the community at-large and our elected officials on all levels. For at the end of the day, it is not “us” against “them,” but simply and collectively, “US”.

The Chamber leadership met recently with Senator Michot. We will work side-by-side as we face a most challenging 2011 legislative session. With Senator Michot as Chairman of the powerful Finance Committee, and the balance of our talented delegation, Lafayette has an unprecedented opportunity for spectacular progress.
Flo Meadows, chairman of the board
Jerry Greig, chairman-elect
Rob Guidry, president

Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (14)add
...
written by ChamberGrader , February 07, 2011 - 05:22 pm
I give the Chamber an F in their methodology.

"However, the simple idea of reporting on voting records brings with it the inherent risk" -- Inherent risk?!!

"The Chamber, in reporting on voting records, provides numerical scores and not letter scores." --- You gave the guy an "F". If that's not a letter, than I don't know what is.

"Thus, the unintended consequences were that a proven friend of the chamber and community received a low numerical score, which mischaracterizes Senator Michot’s legislative contribution." ---- Unintended Consequences?!!

C'mon Man!! Sounds like the Chamber needs to refocus on Education - OF ITSELF!!

You damaged a proven friend of business' reputation. I didn't see an apology, or 'WE WERE WRONG' anywhere.

The Chamber falls directly in the "Couillon" Category in my grading scale.
...
written by ChamberGrader , February 07, 2011 - 05:23 pm
The Chamber, in reporting on voting records, provides numerical scores and not letter scores." --- You gave the guy an "F". If that's not a letter, than I don't know what is.

"Thus, the unintended consequences were that a proven friend of the chamber and community received a low numerical score, which mischaracterizes Senator Michot’s legislative contribution." ---- Unintended Consequences?!!

C'mon Man!! Sounds like the Chamber needs to refocus on Education - OF ITSELF!!

You damaged a proven friend of business' reputation. I didn't see an apology, or 'WE WERE WRONG' anywhere.

The Chamber falls directly in the "Couillon" Category in my grading scale.
...
written by Cajun Yodeler , February 07, 2011 - 06:41 pm
If anyone would read why the Chamber gave the F then you would agree. Ponder this, should not an elective representative do what he was elected to do? Nevertheless, it is good the Chamber is giving Michot a make up test. Good luck Mike and no cheating!
...
written by Plumpy , February 07, 2011 - 06:51 pm
Michot is a major F up . This political clown cares more about his business bud's than the common man. Guess that's because the man on the street can't come up with big donation's like his business buddy's. Especially his insurance bud's . Michot is responsible for raising the insurance coverage on liability for auto's. Just because other states had higher coverage than Louisiana. Why didn't you move to those states Michot ?. Why screw us ? I don't have a good word for that S.o.B. I'll never vote for that thing.. REPUBLICAN TRASH !
...
written by Xchamber , February 07, 2011 - 07:40 pm
Well the Chamebr lost my support when they offered their support of LUS Fiber. The Chamber of COMMERCE is supposed to support free enterprise and be the voice of BUSINESS, not government. Shame on you, Lafayette Chamber, for getting so involved in politics that you forgot your "place."
...
written by Mary Jeansonne , February 08, 2011 - 02:22 am
I disagree with the chamber's F grade of Mike Michot's work in the Legislature. His interests and concerns have been not ONLY for his constituents but, what is good for the ENTIRE state of Louisiana. A rare quality among legislators. His chairmanship of such an important legislative committee is vital to the growth of LA. We need more legislators who have a broad vision. We can no longer think of only local problems, but of what is good for all the people of LA. He needs our support and gratitude. He has been a positive force in the legislature and works for the overall growth of LA ,as well as , Lafayette.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , February 08, 2011 - 03:30 am
The CC members want to play ball with the big boys as in the big leagues of politics and the little midget minds have'nt the first clue. Ya, have to have Balls and a big Baton to play with the big leagues.......and you, Lafayette Chamber of Commerce inbred couillion council members, have not a single set of balls among the lot of you,nor a baton.It's a man thing.
What Lafayette needs is for Mike to bust your inbred couillion
circle jerks ring, by getting elected, Lafayette President/ Lafayette Mayor/Lafayette First Man, now that would be fitting, considering, we have not had a Mayor who has not sold out his gonads for a PRICE. Mike, pass a law against the old illegal practice of the council to block any new businesses from entering the city and un-monopolizing their friends and business cronys cornered business markets. Isn't that correct LOWE'S,& Home Depot, " You finally broke their backs, EH ?
" MIKE TELL THEM TO GO TAKE A FLYING SEXCAPADE. Aw hell, I'm smartin.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , February 08, 2011 - 03:38 am
Plumpy is a chumpy of the circle jerk couillions, HA-HA if you ever rear end me, you won't have enough insurance, and there goes the farm.
...
written by Dr. Strange Luv , February 09, 2011 - 02:05 am
written by Xchamber "the Chamebr lost my support when they offered their support of LUS Fiber."
----------------

Agreed. The Chamber and the City over estimated how many business would support LUS Fiber. What's next? A LUS restaurant? Car dealer? No thanks, and no thanks to LUS fiber.
...
written by The Original Northsidian , February 09, 2011 - 11:45 am
Rob Guidry & Co. tap dance better than Sammy Davis Jr. Plus when you speak to him (Rob) it sounds like a pre-recorded message!
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , February 09, 2011 - 03:25 pm
You are so correct, Rob is a programmed chump as are THE WHOLE PACK, the chamber has one agenda, and that is to obey the commands of the zooschlag, Allen, and the Festermaker Surveyhomme, like a zombie group, mindless parasite's
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , February 09, 2011 - 03:42 pm
Oh Mike, you know who led the Chamber to the stupid grading. It reeks the stench of the above mentioned wannabe power brokers, Zooschlag, Allen, and the Surveyman Fester, you should know that the voters here had you in office for a reason and it sure in hell is not for you to geneflect to these imbeciles, I can imagine the Laughs the Chamber generated, loud and clear, "They gave the message to the all the other state legislators, of their complete lack of support for their own legislator, voted to the office by the voters of his district, this also blows one's mind, how stupid the insult, to the voters who elected you.
...
written by Gene Broussard , February 11, 2011 - 12:59 am
Neither the Chamber or Michot are worth wasting all of this time on. Both are self concerned and selfish hypocrites.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , February 11, 2011 - 07:22 am
Ga ! Gene,don't take sides, you just hate everyone, Eh ?
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
LA LA Land
Advertisement
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it