News -> INDReporter TUE, JUL 12 11:01AM by Walter Pierce

‘Two Dads’ case heads to SCOTUS

A lawsuit against a Louisiana official filed by a gay couple who want both of their names on their adopted child’s birth certificate may be heard by the United States Supreme Court. A gay rights organization, Lambda Legal, has asked justices to consider the case of Oren Adar and Mickey Ray Smith. The defendant in the case is Darlene Smith, state registrar and director of the Department of Health and Hospital’s Office of Vital Records. The child was born in Louisiana and adopted in New York by Adar and Smith, who lived in New Orleans at the time. The couple now lives in Orlando, Fla.

Earlier this year the federal 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans ruled in favor of the state, finding that the registrar’s decision not to list both men on the birth certificate did not vilate the child’s right to equal protection, according to The Wall Street Journal.

If the U.S. Supreme Court declines to hear the case, the 5th Circuit ruling against the couple will stand.

Read more here.


Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (14)add
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , July 12, 2011 - 12:07 pm
What a confusing issue, pray tell how two men can be responsible for the existence of this child, egad not even by immaculate conception. Impossible !
...
written by What the H , July 12, 2011 - 12:14 pm
Two Dads? It must be a miracle of modern science.
...
written by Old Coot , July 12, 2011 - 12:38 pm
"couple now lives in Orlando, Fla."

Are sure? I thought is was Key West.
...
written by Gypsyfox , July 12, 2011 - 12:54 pm
I'm sure the child will appreciate that he/she had "two dads" who wanted him/her rather than a "mom" or "mom and dad" who obviously didn't or couldn't. Shame on Northsidian Shotgun and What the H for trying to make this a joke about reproductive possibilities (and probably a little homophobia) instead of a testament about love.
...
written by Erin Fitzgerald , July 12, 2011 - 12:56 pm
This issue has recently affected two friends of mine - a married man and woman. When they married, she kept her maiden name and did not take his name. They recently had their first child and the state would not allow them to include both the mother's and father's last names.

This has been a painful issue for the mother and her family, in particular.

It is time for Louisiana to move on and progress! More and more women are choosing not to take their husband's names when they marry and more and more couple are choosing not to marry at all! Louisiana needs to allow both parents' names on the birth certificate.
...
written by Erik , July 12, 2011 - 12:56 pm
He was adopted, God bless them for wanting to provide a home for the child. I know plenty of straight couples who shouldnt have children, perhaps the child was better off rotting in an orphanage?
...
written by JoCo , July 12, 2011 - 01:03 pm
Two dads are perfectly capable of loving a child as much as your "traditional" family would be. If the two are raising the child, should something happen to either parent or child, all should be entitled to the rights that anyone else would be allowed.

Stop making Louisiana look so backwards. We need to move progressively forward.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , July 13, 2011 - 01:10 am
To accept homosexuality is to be progressive. Huh ?
Yeah Gypsyfox, father Gauthe was full of love.
The definition of Marriage is a MAN and a Woman unite in legal matrimony. Thats the size of it, you can cut it in any way, and put it all back together, and it is still the size of it, as it will always be. Gay marriage should be legalised the day two men or two women can REPRODUCE. This may not be an accepted fact by those afflicted with ignorancy, but because a person cannot accept homosexuality has not a single solitary connection with any gobbley root phobia, it is very likely that the person just has a distaste for same sex. When sex with an opposite sex partner is so pleasant wholly hygenic. Now, does this not make sense.
...
written by What the H , July 13, 2011 - 08:34 am
by Gypsyfox "Shame on Northsidian Shotgun and What the H for trying to make this a joke about reproductive possibilities (and probably a little homophobia) instead of a testament about love.
---------------------

I am gay, so the joke is on you.

...
written by Findem , July 13, 2011 - 08:49 am
What does Father Gauthe have to do with this story, Northsidian? He was a pedophile, not a homosexual...
...
written by Erik , July 13, 2011 - 03:12 pm
@ NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN - is ignorancy even a word? perhanps in your IGNORANT little world it is. Let religion defend marriage, then when a gay couple wants to marry in the catholic church, they will not allow them, however the government has no place meddling in the defenition of love, thusly government sanctioned marriages should not be backed by an ultra right wing conservative view.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , July 13, 2011 - 09:57 pm
Father Gauthe wore both hats .
And Ignorancy is a word. Humph ! I coined it. Just like you and yours coined the word " Gay = unhygenic sexual conduct.
If you cannot reproduce then you cannot become a union in matrimony. This is an enacted law by the high courts of this land just like the beastiality law.
Oh, by the way, "Love is a two way street", it has to run both ways for it to legally and morally be declared love.

And GypsyFox the joke is on you, for I'm just ecstatic that you are "GAY.
There but for the grace of a higher power, go I...
...
written by Dmr06 , July 13, 2011 - 09:58 pm
@Northsidian: Should heterosexual couples who are unable to reproduce (ie: sterile), be allowed to marry?
...
written by Dagnabbit Jones , July 14, 2011 - 12:21 pm
written by Dmr06 , July 13, 2011 - 09:58 pm
@Northsidian: Should heterosexual couples who are unable to reproduce (ie: sterile), be allowed to marry?
------------------------

Marry? There are some who should not be allowed to reproduce, married or not.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
LA LA Land
Advertisement
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it