News -> INDReporter TUE, FEB 28 11:57AM by John Kennedy, Louisiana treasurer

Kennedy: Solons should sub teach

Governor Jindal has made the improvement of our public schools the top priority of his second term.  He has promised bold reform. Thank you, Governor.

Constructive change requires understanding, however. How many of the officials who will help craft a new direction for pre-K to 12 have first-hand knowledge of what a 21st century public school classroom is like?

For that reason, the state legislature should ask each of its members, all statewide elected officials and members of the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education to substitute teach in a Louisiana public school at least one time in 2012. I’m not talking about speaking 20 minutes to a civics class. I mean being an actual substitute teacher-just the public official and 25 kids-for a full day.

Most Louisiana public school systems have a shortage of available substitutes. I’ve been a volunteer substitute teacher for several years in the East Baton Rouge Parish public schools. I’ve taught 6th, 7th and 11th graders. I learned a lot.

One of the things I learned was that is harder to be a teacher today than when I grew up. That’s why it’s critical to put the best teacher we can in every classroom. Most teachers start around 6:45 a.m., teach an average of five classes, often are assigned lunch room, recess or bus duty, and then have to prepare for the next day. Many are coaches of athletic teams or advisors to school clubs, and are available out of class to answer students’ questions or provide extra help. Teachers today are also expected to be social workers, psychologists, counselors and, too often, parental substitutes.

It’s also harder to teach today because of the problem of discipline in the classroom. A single misbehaving student can disrupt an entire class, and too often teachers do not receive support from school administrators or parents in making a student behave.

I also learned that it is harder to be a kid today. 6th and 7th graders in our public schools now experience things I never saw until I was an adult. An 11-year-old should not have to confront challenges like illicit drugs, alcohol, tobacco, teenage pregnancy, bullying, gang violence and parental indifference, but too many do every day in our public schools. Most of us believe, or should believe, that every child can learn, given the opportunity, but try substitute teaching just once and you will see firsthand the socioeconomic issues that distract our kids from taking advantage of that opportunity.

In the past I’ve suggested several times that the legislature ask elected officials to substitute teach.  Some of my colleagues have laughed at me. They won’t laugh, however, if they try it, because there’s nothing funny about public education in Louisiana and America today. If improvements to our public schools begin in the classroom, as we know they do, shouldn’t we ask our state officials to spend some time there? They’ll learn more about public education in one day of substitute teaching than by reading entire volumes of policy reports.

John Kennedy is the Louisiana state treasurer.


Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (3)add
...
written by Nancy Landry , February 28, 2012 - 07:04 pm
Not a bad idea, but I wonder if Mr. Kennedy's child attends public school. As a legislator and a parent of students in the government run school system, I would like to see the debate focused on the needs of the children rather than on the needs of teachers. We've heard the discipline excuse for too long. I refuse to believe that Louisiana's children behave so badly that they can't be educated. Almost every other state in the nation is able to educate their children better than we manage to educate ours. Are Louisiana kids really that much worse than other U.S. kids or are we just using that as an excuse? Also, I don't know where Mr. Kennedy attended school, but when I was in middle/high school, I observed all of the things mentioned, i.e., drugs, tobacco, teenage pregnancy, violence, and alcohol. Things weren't perfect back then either. Let's stop looking for reasons Louisiana children can't learn and start looking for ways to reach them. Our future depends on it.
...
written by Michael A. Moss , February 28, 2012 - 10:59 pm
Nancy, stop the tap dancing & spinning. Do you think the lege's should sub or not?
...
written by Regan Coussan , February 28, 2012 - 11:25 pm
Mr. Kennedy makes several very, very good points, best summed up by the very truthful statement that teachers today are asked to deal with a great deal more idiocy than they should; a trend which has been growing for at least half a century. It is hypocritical to poke at him about where his children go to school; I would frankly mortgage my body if necessary to prevent any child of mine from attending some of the public schools in which my family has been educated and indeed worked over the years.

Frankly, the idea of career state officials getting a true idea of what is being provided for our children by actually getting their hands dirty for a change seems a fine idea indeed. Better yet, do not tell the administration that said officials are coming -- now there would be a "reality show" I might actually deign to watch!

Don't agree with me? Let me provide an example: My wife has a Folklore M.S. with a Journalism B.A. and is very used to dealing with troublesome people of several ages. She has been praised for "dissertation-worthy thesis work," and actually took more English courses than the average English teacher as well as a certification-worthy set of education courses. Yet she, a very apt teacher who substituted for years and has taught as college-level adjunct faculty pre- and post-thesis, found some schools completely intolerable.

There are several anecdotes from which I might draw, but most memorable of those stories, at the moment, was the eight-year-old who flatly told her that he was "Leavin' and goin' whe'evah I want to." and ran out of the class and down the hall, and had to be gathered by administration staff.

Teachers ARE often expected to parent, in addition to the counseling that every teacher has given ad infinitum. Yet, I do not think that it is the fault of the teacher in maintaining discipline, but the fault of our community, and indeed our national society, from taking away the tools that teachers have always had for dealing with the worst discipline problems, due to fuzzy-headed foolishness about corporal punishments doing psychological harm. Read Heinlein -- a human being does not have an innate moral compass, but instead, if he or she is lucky, a highly trained conscience. When I was a boy, I would never have thought of doing half of the things that I hear about students doing weekly if not daily. And I guarantee you, I sure in the hell did NOT have to deal with teen pregnancy, drugs gangs or violence beyond a schoolyard brawl, for which we all definitely paid. Why? Because teachers were the ultimate authority, and because my parents were very interested in reinforcing both the rewards and penalties accrued in my educational career.

So yes, as one of several generations of teachers, I believe that the blame lies plainly with the foolishness of politics. I do not think that Louisiana children cannot learn -- we are all from a very determined and hard-working community simply full of intelligent and creative people. I think that we need to stop aiming for the lowest common denominator and allowing children, AND PARENTS to get away with doing things that unacceptable, and that our outlook on how this is accomplished MUST CHANGE. I think that partisan squabbling must end, and people like Ms. Landry must offer practical assistance instead of spending their time trying to catch others out.

I do agree with Ms Landry of the state about one thing, though -- it all must be remedied, our future depends upon it.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
LA LA Land
Advertisement
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it