News -> Walter Pierce RE:

RE: Forum for Change (We Can’t Believe In)

Tonight on TV, President Obama will address a joint session of Congress in an effort to reclaim the health care reform debate from what most Democrats no doubt perceive to be a new generation of nabobs of negativity. Let’s give the Tea Party crowd credit — they’ve brought guff to a whole new level, and reinforced that America remains a vital democracy given to nattering, and to homemade signs. I suspect Gov. Bobby Jindal will not be tapped by the GOP to offer another button-eyed rebuttal following the president’s address, but Republicans will almost certainly get time from the networks for a rejoinder. 
 
That wasn’t so much the case last week when KLFY, the local CBS affiliate and a card-carrying member of the mainstream media, broadcast an hour-long health care forum produced by a TV station in Shreveport. Indeed, it had all the trappings of a forum: a panel of politicians fielding questions from the public, with a handsome, honey-toned anchorman functioning as moderator. But the panel members — Louisiana congressmen John Fleming, Bill Cassidy and our own Charles Boustany — are all Republican physicians opposed to Obama’s health care reform plans. It was slow-pitch softball with a very shallow fence.
 
Local Dems knew this ahead of time because the forum aired the night before on the Shreveport station, and they were understandably piqued by the one-sided presentation. They sent a letter to KLFY demanding equal time. The station argued the forum was legitimately news-worthy and offered the donkeys 90 seconds to air their grievances immediately following the broadcast. The Democrats passed.
 
It’s a shame it went down like that, regardless of your position on health care reform — both camps generally agree reform is needed; it’s really a matter of how to do it. But KLFY has an obligation as a news station to present both sides of the story, although with the 1987 repeal of the FCC’s Fairness Doctrine, which gave birth to the screaming baby that is talk radio as we know it today, it is apparently not legally obligated to do so. 
 
The forum was also broadcast in Lake Charles, yet there was not so much as a peep about fairness from Democrats outside of Lafayette; in fact, the Caddo Parish Democratic Executive Committee evidently no longer exists, and the latest news on the Calcasieu branch’s Web site is a June release titled, “STAND WITH SOTOMAYOR.” That they are still standing with Sotomayor is a tribute to tenacity. 
 
Rep. Fleming, it’s worth noting, is also CEO of the Fleming Group, which owns Subway restaurant franchises in several states. The 20 percent of his employees who qualify for company-provided health insurance are offered health savings accounts, which the company switched to from a traditional health insurance plan several years ago due to rising premiums. Fleming himself was on the company plan until he became a U.S. representative, at which time he joined the government-run plan offered to members of Congress. The Fleming Group contributes $850 annually to each employee’s health savings account. The annual deductible is $3,300. Do not slip on that hunk of sweet onion teriyaki.

Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (13)add
...
written by Jim Smyth , September 09, 2009 - 08:03 am
Pierce fails to mention the most important thing about the forum. That is that KTBS scoured the state to find any, ANY Democrat who would participate in the forum. The only one that could be found was a Democrat Physician, Dr. Dawson, who recanted just before air time. Pierce, you need to tell the whole truth next time.
...
written by Tiredofit , September 09, 2009 - 09:30 am
Yes, really unfair. It reminds me of how Obama is going to get a full hour of national air time to press his healthcare agenda, then Dr. Boustany will be given five minutes for rebuttal.

FYI, the government plan offered to member of Congress is basically a menu of private plans from which they get to choose. Granted, they are really good plans paid for by the taxpayer that most of us could never afford. . .but they are private health plans.

Mr. Pierce, you've made it plainly obvious in all of your columns that you are a Democrat. That's fine. But take a minute to go back and review your articles. The large majority have a more than left-leaning slant and are riddled with inaccuracies (as Mr. Jim Smyth aptly points out). My question is this: Does the ironically-named "Independent" purport itself to be a credible "Independent" news source? If so, why the recurring theme of bias toward the Left and against the Right?

I've thoroughly enjoyed the addition of The Independent to our area. I think, for the most part, it does a great job of covering topics important to our area that would otherwise go uncovered. That being said, everytime a venture is made into the political arena its the same old thing: a news outlet that presents the story it wants you to see, not the actual story. Please fix it. The Advertiser works very well for my crawfish and crab boils. . .I'd hate to have to make the switch.
...
written by Stephen The Dem , September 09, 2009 - 10:33 am
Mr. Smyth - that is not actually true. They did not "scour the state" in fact they never even called the state party office or the Caddo Parish Democrats about this issue as we have scores of Doctors, Nurses and others who would have been more than qualified and able to be part of this panel. Instead they turned to the National Democratic Party and they simply gave them a name of someone. And he didn't cancel "at the last minute" but infact canceled first thing on Monday morning before the Wednesday taping due to him coming down with the Flu.

UPDATE THOUGH - KLFY has offered the Democrats 60 minutes to put together our own forum and we are working with them now to put that together. We will update the public when that is scheduled. We thank KLFY for recognizing that both sides should be heard on this matter and see this as their firm commitment to the community as a whole.

Stephen Handwerk
...
written by justwundering , September 09, 2009 - 10:34 am
I have to give Mr. Pierce credit, the article may be biased, but at least he didn't mention Vitter's name, a first for him....
...
written by Walter Pierce, Managing Editor , September 09, 2009 - 10:44 am
People, please! If I wrote a column about roses I'd be accused of a bias against daisies!
So I rib a TV station for a one-sided forum, rib state Democrats for an overall flaccid response thereto and acknowledge that both sides of the debate agree that health care reform is needed.
Can I do nothing right? (pun intended)
...
written by ADS , September 09, 2009 - 11:05 am
I think Congressman Boustany's 5 minutes will be a bit more beneficial than the 1 hour spin cycle from the President based on nothing else than the Doctor's knowledge on the healthcare topic.

I find it interesting that if a media outlet does not confirm your our personal position on "insert topic here" they are immediately labeled as biased. I wonder if we treated our friends, family, and neighbors the same way we would find ourselves alone in in own self absorbed worlds drinking nothing else than poltical Kool-Aid all day long.

...
written by Surfing Jesus , September 09, 2009 - 02:40 pm
written by Tiredofit , September 09, 2009
Yes, really unfair. It reminds me of how Obama is going to get a full hour of national air time to press his healthcare agenda, then Dr. Boustany will be given five minutes for rebuttal.

One hour Obama, five minutes Boustany, the weather channel is looking good.
...
written by Straight Talker , September 09, 2009 - 07:11 pm
Lets be honest here, how many really ever watch a rebuttal speech? So predictable each and every time, so please wipe the tears and prep yourself for some football action this weekend. So immature to even whine on such.
...
written by Walter Pierce, Managing Editor , September 09, 2009 - 08:57 pm
Thank you, Straight Talker, for some perspective.
Don Banks at SI, as you probably know, raised da Saints up to 7 in his post-pre-season power rankings. We shall see.
In the meantime, I'll be at Cajun Field Saturday night for what I'm confident will be a very minor upset by the home team, Snyder's return to coaching notwithstanding.
...
written by Jason D , September 10, 2009 - 09:19 am
As a democrat myself, I must say that I find it funny that the Independent has chosen to target TV10. KPEL FM is obviously in every way Pro-Republican. Do you people ever listen to the views on that radio station? I think not! I also feel that if you are going to write a story perhaps you should have all the information first.
...
written by WTF? , September 10, 2009 - 05:04 pm
Folks, the point is not that KLFY aired an obviously right biased piece of disinformation. As Jason D. correctly pointed out, that is par for the course for media outlets in this hopelessly red state. The point is that the program was disguised and presented as a debate format for all views on these issues and not as the propaganda piece it obviously was for the wingnut point of view.
...
written by Lard of the Rings , September 14, 2009 - 06:23 pm
"UPDATE THOUGH - KLFY has offered the Democrats 60 minutes to put together our own forum . . . Stephen Handwerk"

Another waste of valuable TV time. Me, I be watching Kanye West on MTV.


...
written by RealityBytes , September 24, 2009 - 01:00 pm
I don't watch Channel 10. I have principles.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
Advertisement

Read the Flipping Paper!

Click Here for the Entire Print Version of
IND Monthly

Read the Dining Guide

Click Here for the Entire Print Version of
IND Eats Dining Guide
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it