Written by Walter Pierce
Wednesday, 17 March 2010
A weighted vote could be the salve that soothes our consolidated sores
The breathless deconsolidation talk that swept Lafayette began Feb. 1 when a charter committee advanced an ordinance that would put repeal of the City-Parish Home Rule Charter up for a parishwide vote. It wasn’t supposed to be that way.
One of the main reasons City-Parish Council Chair Jay Castille appointed the committee in the first place was to look at tweaking the existing charter, particularly with regard to wording in the charter concerning the Lafayette Public Utility Authority, the governing body of city-owned Lafayette Utilities System — our multi-billion dollar public utility. We’re all pretty well versed now in why the LPUA issue was troublesome: The charter says the five members of the council with at least 60 percent LUS customers in their districts shall comprise the LPUA. But if LUS matters are decided by the LPUA only, some LUS customers in the other four districts don’t get a seat at the table. That’s a few thousand people disenfranchised. So the whole nine-member council has a say about LUS. Consequently, non-LUS customers in the parish, through their council members, can influence decisions about LUS. That’s a big problem.
The perfect remedy is a weighted vote, and it’s a remedy Castille favors and is likely to be considered by a charter commission appointed in the coming weeks.
Here’s how it would work: On matters related to LUS, a council member’s vote would represent the percentage of all LUS customers residing in his district. According to recent demographics, the vote of Sam Doré of District 6, the most populous city/LUS district, would count for 19 percent of the total vote, followed by Keith Patin (18 percent), Don Bertrand (16), Kenneth Boudreaux (15), Brandon Shelvin (13), Jay Castille (7), Jared Bellard (5), William Theriot (4) and Purvis Morrison (3). Doré’s vote would count for six times that of Morrison, who has six times fewer LUS customers in his district.
If a weighted vote were instituted, the LPUA could be abolished; there would be no need for it — all LUS customers, the utility’s stakeholders, would have a say in their public utility. As important, non-LUS customers would effectively be shut out of the conversation, as they should be.
Now before we commence the hue and cry of “one person, one vote,” let’s acknowledge that a weighted voting system isn’t a totally alien or new system. I can’t find an example of it being used close to home, but a statewide taxing body in New York uses it; those districts that collect more taxes have more say than those that collect fewer taxes. And the use of a weighted vote is common in the corporate world — it is how decisions are made at shareholders meetings — the shareholder with 5,000 shares has 10 times the voting power of the shareholder with 500 shares.
So take for example the Feb. 2 vote on the LUS rate hike. It cleared the full council 5-4. Voting in favor were Doré, Patin, Bertrand, Castille and Morrison; Shelvin, Boudreaux, Bellard and Theriot voted against. If that vote were weighted, the rate increase would have passed 63 percent to 37 percent. That’s actually a stronger margin of victory than 5-4.
To introduce a weighted vote to the Lafayette City-Parish Council — it would only be used for city-related votes like LUS; votes on parish matters would remain full-council, one man-one vote — the council would and could adopt an electronic voting system similar to what the Lafayette Parish School Board uses. The existing charter, however, prohibits electronic voting.
Castille, who has directed the LCG legal department to draft an ordinance creating a charter commission, hopes that commission will look into adopting both electronic voting and the weighted vote. I asked him if he was OK with his vote on LUS being worth only 7 percent of the total. “Yes sir, because that’s the amount of people I represent that use the service. I don’t have a problem with that,” was his ready response.
Short of deconsolidating Lafayette Parish, this could solve a lot of our problems.
Breakfast favorites served on a bubbly crust pair with a crisp salad
State Rep. Lenar Whitney — one of a handful of Republican candidates vying for Louisiana’s 6th Congressional district — has been described by Cook Political Report analyst David Wasserman as one of the most “frightening or fact-averse candidate[s]” he’s ever met following her reaction to an interview last week.
West coast casual
Mid-August hearing dates have been set for dueling lawsuits over Louisiana's use of the Common Core education standards in public schools.
An investigation into the last-minute passage of a pension hike for the state police superintendent continues, despite Col. Mike Edmonson's decision not to accept the increase.
Four bedroom traditional Youngsville home or three bedroom traditional Broussard home
On Tuesday, a three judge panel (voting two to one) of the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down as unconstitutional Mississippi’s controversial law requiring that physicians who perform abortions maintain admitting privileges in a nearby hospital.
Safety Jairus Byrd practiced with the New Orleans Saints on Tuesday for the first time since his signing in March.
Sentencing has been delayed for a businessman who provided key testimony in the corruption case that resulted in the conviction of former New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin.
The spectre of priest sex abuse has returned to haunt the Roman Catholic Diocese of Lafayette following the recent release of an investigative report by Minnesota Public Radio, revealing new allegations of another child predator hiding behind the clerical collar.
Acadiana's nightlife guide.
Wednesday's Blogs from the Bog!
A ballpark snack topped with BBQ meat can be found cruising town on a food truck
Times Square impersonator crackdown; Israel shells Gaza school; Russia hit with sanctions and more national and international news for Wednesday, July 30, 2014.
"Although the administration is moving forward with climate change regulations at home, we don't consider how policy decisions in the United States impact greenhouse gas emissions in other parts of the world," says Roger Martella, the former general counsel at the Environmental Protection Agency under President George W. Bush.
Louisiana agriculture officials say prices for long-grain rice are projected to drop this year.
First-time claims for unemployment insurance in Louisiana for the week ending July 19 decreased from the previous week's total.
A judge is getting ready to set a new trial date for a former BP executive charged with obstructing a congressional investigation into the 2010 Gulf of Mexico oil spill.
The sponsor of a Louisiana law that requires doctors that perform abortions to have hospital admitting privileges doesn't believe the provision is in jeopardy after a federal appeals court struck down a similar Mississippi law.
Louisiana's state school board has jumped into a lawsuit against Gov. Bobby Jindal that accuses the governor of illegally meddling in education policy through his efforts to block Common Core education standards.
Here's how one nationally recognized conservative political pundit reacted upon hearing the news Monday that the U.S. Chamber of Commerce was leaning toward an endorsement of Louisiana’s lone Democrat senator.
If President Barack Obama’s poll numbers, and those for his health care law, haven’t yet bottomed out in the Bayou State, then Democrats surely don’t want to know what the statistical floor actually looks like.
Midsouth Bank has released its second quarter earnings report, showing a year-over-year increase for shareholders.
The comeback of the Wayfarer
Two bedroom New Iberia ranch style house or two bedroom Lafayette condo
The deadline to purchase tickets for the 2014 ABiz Top 50 Business Luncheon featuring top-selling author, political activist and Harvard law professor Lawrence Lessig is only two weeks away.
With the qualifying deadline for Lafayette Parish School Board elections quickly approaching, a series of candidate forums have been announced by the Lafayette Parish Public Education Stakeholders Council.
Acadiana's nightlife guide.
The investigation and potential prosecution of the man charged in the recent hit-and-run death of a Youngsville cyclist won’t happen overnight, according to local law enforcement officials.
Louisiana's state school board is holding a special meeting to consider whether to sue Gov. Bobby Jindal in an ongoing dispute over the Common Core education standards.