Written by Walter Pierce
Wednesday, 17 March 2010
A weighted vote could be the salve that soothes our consolidated sores
The breathless deconsolidation talk that swept Lafayette began Feb. 1 when a charter committee advanced an ordinance that would put repeal of the City-Parish Home Rule Charter up for a parishwide vote. It wasn’t supposed to be that way.
One of the main reasons City-Parish Council Chair Jay Castille appointed the committee in the first place was to look at tweaking the existing charter, particularly with regard to wording in the charter concerning the Lafayette Public Utility Authority, the governing body of city-owned Lafayette Utilities System — our multi-billion dollar public utility. We’re all pretty well versed now in why the LPUA issue was troublesome: The charter says the five members of the council with at least 60 percent LUS customers in their districts shall comprise the LPUA. But if LUS matters are decided by the LPUA only, some LUS customers in the other four districts don’t get a seat at the table. That’s a few thousand people disenfranchised. So the whole nine-member council has a say about LUS. Consequently, non-LUS customers in the parish, through their council members, can influence decisions about LUS. That’s a big problem.
The perfect remedy is a weighted vote, and it’s a remedy Castille favors and is likely to be considered by a charter commission appointed in the coming weeks.
Here’s how it would work: On matters related to LUS, a council member’s vote would represent the percentage of all LUS customers residing in his district. According to recent demographics, the vote of Sam Doré of District 6, the most populous city/LUS district, would count for 19 percent of the total vote, followed by Keith Patin (18 percent), Don Bertrand (16), Kenneth Boudreaux (15), Brandon Shelvin (13), Jay Castille (7), Jared Bellard (5), William Theriot (4) and Purvis Morrison (3). Doré’s vote would count for six times that of Morrison, who has six times fewer LUS customers in his district.
If a weighted vote were instituted, the LPUA could be abolished; there would be no need for it — all LUS customers, the utility’s stakeholders, would have a say in their public utility. As important, non-LUS customers would effectively be shut out of the conversation, as they should be.
Now before we commence the hue and cry of “one person, one vote,” let’s acknowledge that a weighted voting system isn’t a totally alien or new system. I can’t find an example of it being used close to home, but a statewide taxing body in New York uses it; those districts that collect more taxes have more say than those that collect fewer taxes. And the use of a weighted vote is common in the corporate world — it is how decisions are made at shareholders meetings — the shareholder with 5,000 shares has 10 times the voting power of the shareholder with 500 shares.
So take for example the Feb. 2 vote on the LUS rate hike. It cleared the full council 5-4. Voting in favor were Doré, Patin, Bertrand, Castille and Morrison; Shelvin, Boudreaux, Bellard and Theriot voted against. If that vote were weighted, the rate increase would have passed 63 percent to 37 percent. That’s actually a stronger margin of victory than 5-4.
To introduce a weighted vote to the Lafayette City-Parish Council — it would only be used for city-related votes like LUS; votes on parish matters would remain full-council, one man-one vote — the council would and could adopt an electronic voting system similar to what the Lafayette Parish School Board uses. The existing charter, however, prohibits electronic voting.
Castille, who has directed the LCG legal department to draft an ordinance creating a charter commission, hopes that commission will look into adopting both electronic voting and the weighted vote. I asked him if he was OK with his vote on LUS being worth only 7 percent of the total. “Yes sir, because that’s the amount of people I represent that use the service. I don’t have a problem with that,” was his ready response.
Short of deconsolidating Lafayette Parish, this could solve a lot of our problems.
A state district judge is deciding whether to issue an injunction against the enforcement of a last-minute retirement hike that lawmakers gave to the state police superintendent.
A new website is up for Louisiana's state government employees and retirees to choose their health insurance plans for next year, a choice they must make by October.
Radisson dumps NFL sponsorship over abuse; troops sent to fight Ebola; bomber kills troops and more national and international news for Tuesday, September 16, 2014.
Tuesday's Blogs from the Bog!
That fact that New Orleans led both games in the final 10 seconds of regulation, and lost each by a field goal or less, is of little solace.
The superintendent will make another go at getting a budget passed for the already commenced fiscal year as the LPSB is slated to meet tonight on the eve of the state’s budget adoption deadline.
A person familiar with the situation says New Orleans Saints running back Mark Ingram has a broken hand.
It seeks an investigation into a $100,000 fund transfer from Vitter's federal campaign account to an independent PAC supporting Vitter's 2015 candidacy for governor.
Landrieu has acknowledged that she improperly billed her Senate office for nearly $43,000 in charter costs that should have been paid from her campaign account.
In this letter to the editor, LaPESC chairman Stephen Bartley looks to the Nov. 4 elections as Lafayette's best chance to rally around a 'Common Vision' for our public education system.
Three bedroom Rayne traditional or two bedroom cottage on the Teche
House District 45 Rep. Joel Robideaux is term-limited and running for city-parish president next year, leaving his seat up for grabs come 2015 and at least three likely contenders so far, including ...
The romper gets all dressed up
Acadiana's nightlife guide.
Authorities said that a Chevron Corp. subsidiary was still releasing natural gas Sunday from a pipeline off the Louisiana coast where a Saturday incident killed a maintenance worker.
When the Browns explained their plans to Brian Hoyer about bringing rookie Johnny Manziel into the game, Cleveland's starting quarterback bit his lip and devised one of his own.
National debate over solitary confinement puts spotlight on Angola inmate’s 35 years in ‘the hole’
Meet the WWMB Class of 2014, extraordinary women guiding our exceptional community
Software development center represents third such project in Hub City this year.
Elizabeth Abdalla and Abform are poised for a new era of growth.
Lafayette’s most highly regarded attorneys were honored by their own at the Hall of Fame Banquet sponsored by the Lafayette Bar Association.
Collaboration and relationships give you the help you want — and the help you need.
A look at recent promotions, hirings and recognitions from Acadiana's business community.
Who doesn’t like grilled cheese?
There has been much progress in the 50 years since the Civil Rights Act was passed, but there is still work to be done.
The state labor department figures released Friday show the initial claims decreased to 1,961 from the previous week's total of 2,237. For the comparable week a year earlier, there were 2,190 claims.
Lafayette’s Ruffino’s on the River has taken its place among our many establishments worthy of note and, in this case, The James Beard Foundation.
If you didn’t know Alison, Sheriff Mike Neustrom’s 42-year-old daughter who died Wednesday after battling cancer for a year, you missed out on something really special.
Three bedroom cottage or two bedroom traditional
Martini contest underway