News -> Walter Pierce RE:

Worst Case Scenarios

Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Written by Walter Pierce

UL Lafayette is planning for the future by preparing for the worst.


Charitably, let’s think of tomorrow’s public policy forum in Baton Rouge hosted by the League of Women Voters as the end of the beginning of higher education in Louisiana, rather than the beginning of the end. At the table will be the presidents of the LSU, UL and Southern University systems as well as the head of the state’s community and technical college system. They’ll be there to discuss the long-term effects of the 2010 budget cuts, which followed a similarly painful round of cuts in 2009 and will almost surely precede more cuts next year. Higher ed and health care have become a sort of rainy day fund that lawmakers use via funding reductions to help balance the budget. But for the grace of the stimulus act, those cuts would have undoubtedly been more severe this year.

I say the end of the beginning because higher education is not going away, but the pressure on university budgets through cuts from the state is changing the dynamic in which they operate. Expect the elimination of more degree programs — UL lost its philosophy degree program last year — as well as a reduction in the workforce.

UL isn’t waiting until next year to find out what its budget reductions will be or how it will proceed as an institution; the administration has begun a review process with the deans of the colleges to create what amounts to worst-case-scenario disaster planning: how to handle a 5-percent, 10-percent or 20-percent cut in funding.

UL Provost Steve Landry says higher ed funding in the near term depends on federal stimulus money, or a lack thereof, but, as the saying goes, forewarned is forearmed. “It’s going to be a full systemic review, and I think it’s unlikely that our strategy would be, ‘O, let’s cut every department 20 percent.’ That’s not the best logic,” Landry says. “The best logic is to look at what’s your strength and what’s your future look like, what do you really want to go after as an institution and a community and then maybe some departments can help us with 20 percent, and maybe I eliminate a unit in the worst-case scenario. I’m trying to take a very strategic approach to this and not just say, ‘We’re going to cut everybody 20 percent.’”

Already on their heels due to proposed changes within the UL System that would make it easier to discontinue academic programs and lay off tenured professors, some faculty members interpreted the review process as a threat, and rumors that draconian cuts were imminent began to circulate.

While faculty positions at UL appear to be safe for at least the current fiscal year, professors have cause for alarm. More budget reductions will come, and in a state like Louisiana where conservatism and its greasy-haired bedfellow, anti-intellectualism, are prominent, the perception that university professors are a bunch of namby-pamby liberals with cushy jobs remains a dangerous undercurrent.

Many outside of higher ed and an increasingly sober number within acknowledge that Louisiana might have too many four-year colleges. But which city in this state will magnanimously step forward and offer to close its university or to severely curtail its scope? Each of us will fight for our local college; it’s critical to our local economy.

UL Lafayette is the second-largest university in the state — a city within our city with an annual budget of roughly $150 million (and shrinking), making it the third largest enterprise in the parish behind consolidated government and the public school system. With about 16,000 students and 2,100 faculty members, it would be the 17th largest city in the state were it to incorporate and secede from Lafayette.

UL also supports about 7,800 non-university jobs, bringing its employment value to Lafayette to about 10,000 jobs. Reductions to higher education in Louisiana hurt us in very practical ways. As a sign at a protest by university professionals in New Orleans last spring put it: Some cuts don’t heal.


Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (14)add
...
written by ragin_cajun , August 18, 2010 - 11:55 am
"conservatism and its greasy-haired bedfellow, anti-intellectualism"

You know, Walter. Every week it's some kind of arrogant insult like this from you. And it's getting worse, too. There were alot of ways to support or defend whatever position you have on higher education--or to simply lay out both sides of the argument. To include a completely unnecessary, untrue, and irrelevant insult in the article is just low. Instead of provoking thought and reasoned debate, you've actually just stirred up resentment and strife. Your credibility with me is shot.

Perhaps it'd be more appropriate for you to save the insults for the comments section AFTER the article.
...
written by Walter Pierce , August 18, 2010 - 03:17 pm
Ragin,
Are you actually suggesting that anti-intellectualism isn't a component of modern conservatism?
You're not actually suggesting that are you?
I would start at Sarah Palin and work my way back, but I have other pots to stir.
...
written by Sparrow , August 18, 2010 - 06:10 pm
I concur with Mr. Pierce: Conservatism and anti-intellectualism go hand-in-hand in Louisiana and elsewhere in the U.S.

I define "anti-intellectualism" not as a dislike of intellectuals per se, but, rather, as a sort of willful ignorance, and as an intense distrust or even fear of reason in favor of emotion. (I think emotion is fine thing for love affairs, but a bad thing for crafting state or national policy.)

G. W. Bush, Sarah Palin, Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Sean Hannity all exhibit a distrust of reason, as well as a distinct inability to detect logical fallacies. They all use fallacious reasoning frequently, more so than your average person, and, in Beck's case, fall for others' irrational theories wholesale (thus partly explaining Beck's penchant for conspiracy theory). It's as if they have no critical thinking skills whatsoever.

I think Walter hit the nail right on the head.

Sparrow (moderate Independent)

...
written by The Original Northsidian , August 18, 2010 - 06:57 pm
Sparrow, I agree with you. But, since I am a crude person, I never could have explained it like you did. Congratulations on being a great wordsmith!! The Power Elite don't like what Walter says because their testicles have never dropped!!
...
written by RCajunRunner , August 19, 2010 - 12:31 am
Walter throws out Sarah Palin as the modern "conservative" movement example. Wasn't long ago that Ted Kennedy was the modern "liberal" movement example. Should we conclude liberalism is based upon being drunk and driving your car off a bridge killing your "side" girl?
...
written by carl cochon , August 19, 2010 - 12:44 am
Don't kid yourselves, education has never been, and is not now,valued in Louisiana. This is,in large part, a nasty by-product of the influence of the oil industry,a legacy of too many folks with no education making 50k in the oil patch. I have advised my own soon to graduate son to look out of state for graduate school. Degrees from Louisiana colleges may be seriously devalued by all of this.
...
written by Resident , August 19, 2010 - 01:11 pm
Ha, Walter knew that comment would ruffle a feather or two but it needs to be said. And Sparrow expounded nicely. Anti-intellectualism is rampant among modern conservatives, at least the ones who make the news and the legions of Fox News addicts. Thoughtful conservatism has been replaced by appeals to emotion, superficial cliches and complete disregard for logic.

What a sad narrative the neocon hucksters push that universities are full of agenda-driven liberal professors. Dispassionate examination of subject matter seems to be a frightening thing to the Fox/Rush/Palin conservative.
...
written by Morrow , August 23, 2010 - 12:24 pm
#1 I support continuing ed in anyone's life, even self taught, correspondance and now, via internet
#2 UNIVERSITIES PUT A HEAVY BURDEN ON THE STUDENTS AND FAMILIES BY MANY, AND SIGNIGICANT, TUITION INCREASES AND FEE INCREASES - so I'm tired of the BS about how "they" are hurting
#3 Louisiana has TOO MANY COLLEGE3S, large and small

#4 I'm sick to death of hearing how hard universities have it, when they're top heavy

#5 DO LEGISLATORS STILL HAVE THE "GIVE AWAY" POLITICAL PAY BACK SCHOLARSHIPS AT TULANE??? How much is a Tulane education and are legislators still able to give them out?

#6 How much $$$$ is wasted like on people like phd Williams?

I'm sick of higher ed being the sacred cow. Williams is proof there is waste and corruption in Louisiana universities. I'll support higher ed in Louisiana when it goes back to the job of educating and not being a cash cow for profs, administators, families of university personnnel, and stays out of local and state political campaigns.

Oh, and also, does anyone know how very little hours can be transferred from other state universites to UL. UL REGULARLY DENIES STUDENTS CREDIT FROM OTHER UNIVERSITIES, LIKE LSU IN BATON ROUGE. Its just a sick way to get more tuition bucks. Its a disgrace to higher ed and Louisiana!

HOW ABOUT DOING AN EXPOSE ON THAT! How few credits can be transferred to ULL.
...
written by ragin_cajun , August 23, 2010 - 07:54 pm
I don't know Morrow...you're sounding pretty anti-intellectual to me. :) Attitudes like yours are dooming this state :) What you need is a tax increase....for the future of our state, of course.
...
written by Morrow , August 24, 2010 - 09:31 am
rc we've been through this revolving door before. What the heck does "anti intelletual" mean? What's an intellecdtual? Are you accusing me of being anti university educated? Again, we've had a round on that. People get on their high horse about govt being too big, yet no one wants to admit higher ed is full of excess. phd Williams is proof of that! Some dont want to admit ULL has its own graft and corruption. Its SO EASY TO PASS ON THE COST TO TUITION PAYERS OR TAX PAYERS.
...
written by Morrow , August 24, 2010 - 09:36 am
I know of a guy who tried to finish up his last year of college here. ULL would not transfer over 30 hrs. He only had 12 to complete at LSU. So he lived in Laf, worked in Laf and commuted to BR his last year. Its "gimmicks" like that that tick me off. ULL will pay bogus profs like Wms, but will deny hours in order to grab more tuition money. Waste and corruption are taking place in higher ed in Louisiana and students are paying for it. Ain't nothing "anti intellectual" about that, just truth.
...
written by Resident , August 24, 2010 - 12:23 pm
Morrow, I think you're right about universities being caught up with making money. The UL credit transfer policy may indeed be a reflection of that. I'm sure this is a complex issue and some things are beyond UL's control.
...
written by Jasper_Noone , August 24, 2010 - 12:58 pm
Morrow:

Your posting is as ignorant as it is frenetic. The Nevers Bill was signed by the Governor and it assures that ALL credit from the 1st and 2nd years can be transferred between Louisiana public institutions.
...
written by Jasper_Noone , August 24, 2010 - 01:01 pm
To Mr. Pierce:

Have you asked the editors at The Chronicle of Higher Education to consider a cover story on Louisiana troubles? I believe what your story needs is national coverage.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
Advertisement

Read the Flipping Paper!

Click Here for the Entire Print Version of
IND Monthly
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it