News -> Walter Pierce RE:

Horseshoes and Hand Grenades

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Greg Davis came within a hair of winning the District 2 school board seat. Lafayette came within a hair of reform. By Walter Pierce

Greg Davis is nothing if not resilient. This newspaper’s admiration for the Cajundome director is well-chronicled, so the timbre of this column will come as little surprise to many.

20101013-re-0101I was reminded last week of how committed Greg is to improving public education in Lafayette Parish, especially for poor students. Just three days removed from losing the election for the District 2 seat on the Lafayette Parish School Board by four votes — four votes! — Davis was back at the stove stirring the pot. I had the opportunity, along with a few other Ind staff members, of sitting down with him. He was upbeat and forward looking, sanguine and resolved. At that point there was no reason to believe that victor Tommy Angelle wouldn’t be the next District 2 rep on the board, and although Greg and a few supporters were watching the post-election process closely for irregularities — how could they not, given the painfully close margin of defeat? — he was already mulling ways of effecting improvements from outside the system, as he has long endeavored. His membership in 100 Black Men — a galvanizing force in preventing the dissolution of N.P. Moss Middle School — and the Lafayette Public Education Stakeholders Council is intact. His research in educational best practices continues. His willingness to challenge the school system and the community to have the highest expectations is unwavering. It’s fair to say the performance of public education would not be a cause célèbre in Lafayette Parish, as much as that can be said, were it not for Davis’ persistence. He keeps his eye on the ball.

Those of us who supported Greg’s candidacy knew it was a long shot — a black man in a white district, a city man in a country district; demographics were against him from the moment he qualified to run.

Within days of this meeting, more performance scores trickled out of the state Department of Education, painting, yet again, a picture of torpor for our parish, and magnifying our sense that an opening for introducing reform into a bureaucracy that resists it had slammed shut.

Most of us have little doubt that the regime in Lafayette public education, both at the administrative and elected levels, has good intentions. But the school system’s lethargic progress is frustrating to say the least. Lafayette’s district performance score climbed just two tenths of a percent, to 96.5 — a growth rate that ranked 43rd in the state. It is foregone that the goal of achieving a 120 DPS by 2013 will not be achieved, and our overall DPS ranking statewide dipped from 22nd to 24th. Being 24th out of 71 school districts in Louisiana makes us the top-performing school system in the middle third — that’s middle of the pack in a state that ranks 47th in the nation.

The number of four-star schools in Lafayette did increase, and the graduation rate climbed a healthy 3.5 percent, from 67.7 to 70.4 percent. Yet neighboring Vermilion Parish’s graduation rate jumped from 67.4 to 81 percent, a 12.5 percent increase. How does this happen? Why them, not us?

By week’s end, as the DOE performance scores added a dark patina to our electoral lamentations, it appeared Greg might have an opening to challenge the election. Four votes is a margin that naturally raises eyebrows, that begs a second look precinct by precinct. Friday morning it appeared there were enough irregularities to challenge. Hours later, after the registrar and secretary of state’s offices satisfied any misgivings, Greg conceded the race. With grace.


Walter Pierce
About the author:


Comments (8)add
...
written by Well said , October 13, 2010 - 03:02 pm
Well said, Walter. My admiration for Mr. Davis and my concern for our public school system continues to grow.
...
written by French Fry Enthusiast , October 13, 2010 - 05:48 pm
Greg Davis deserves credit for not running to Judge Rubin for an injunction. Sometimes things just don't work out. Hey, that's life, you win a few, you lose a few.

P.S. Don't let Walter P. pick your horse at the track. Unless you want to lose money.
...
written by Saimar , October 13, 2010 - 06:33 pm
The City of Lafayette is ranked one of the Top 100 cities in America. Yet, our community seems satisfied to have a school system that ranks 24th in the state. A state with one of the poorest educational systems in the nation. There is no sense of outrage or even of urgency about our public schools. Perhaps it's because 20% of our children are in catholic schools or maybe we're just too nice here in Lafayette. We know the people on our school board and our adminstration. They're nice people "trying their best" so we accept that, while our children continue to underperform. Meanwhile, cities such as Newark, NJ, Wash DC and others are having remarkable results turning around their schools. These cities have higher rates of poverty, crime, drop out, etc yet they have schools that are performing. Meanwhile, we "Wait for Superman". Some of us thought that Mr. Davis might be that "Superman" who would lead the way. Too bad for us and more importantly too bad for the children of Lafayette.
...
written by 2011 , October 13, 2010 - 07:14 pm
Word is Greg Davis conceded without a fight for two main reasons:

1) Not to let one election drag the school system down
2) An agreement to received Angelle's backing for the State Rep. 44 race next year to challege Ricky Hardy.
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , October 14, 2010 - 01:34 am
We elected Earl and Edwin, now why would we elect Greg !
...
written by NORTHSIDIAN SHOTGUN , October 14, 2010 - 02:20 pm
There are some of us that know its GRAY and not Black or White, but that does not deter us from hoping for White and i am not speaking race here, but a system that would benefit those children who cannot wait much longer for the lifesaver, which we fail to provide as most are being led by that dangling carrot .
...
written by Pedro , October 16, 2010 - 01:18 am
"There is no sense of outrage or even of urgency about our public schools. Perhaps it's because 20% of our children are in catholic schools or maybe we're just too nice here in Lafayette. We know the people on our school board and our adminstration. They're nice people "trying their best" so we accept that, while our children continue to underperform. Meanwhile, cities such as Newark, NJ, Wash DC and others are having remarkable results turning around their schools. "

No they are not "nice people, trying their best". Even IF they were, that would not be an acceptable excuse for our crumbling, out of date, moldy, nasty facilities and our low ranking in a low ranking state. We gave Mike Hefner over 20 years to make a difference, he didn't. If the citizens of Lafayette cared about public education, we would have a top ranking system. It is time for the voters to stop being 'nice" and demand more.
...
written by R.Thornton , October 20, 2010 - 01:42 pm
I don't get the love affair with Davis. What has he done in the field of education, other than demand that the nearly-empty, failed Moss remain open ? Others came up with the plan for the technical high school, which is a great idea, on paper.

I have not seen a single, concrete proposal from Davis to "reform" our system.

After having promoted him and "sat down with him", you'd think some of those great ideas might have made their way into one of the articles. Alas, not so.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Log in using your Facebook account or register if you do not have an account yet.

busy 
Advertisement

Read the Flipping Paper!

Click Here for the Entire Print Version of
IND Monthly
Most Read
Advertisement
Advertisement
in case you missed it